Epidemiology, surveillance, and zoonotic aspects of human influenza.
Eric C.J. Claas
Department of Virology, Leiden University Medical Centre, Leiden, The Netherlands
Human influenza viruses annually cause minor or major epidemics with considerable morbidity and mortality. Despite an elaborate WHO network of national influenza centres all over the world and extensive vaccination programmes in many countries, the virus still cannot be controlled. The WHO network provides us with the most recent information on the changes in the circulating influenza viruses, but protection provided by the vaccine will never be complete. One reason is that mutations rapidly accumulate in circulating influenza viruses (antigenic drift) and new variants emerge while the vaccine is being produced. Another reason is that the majority of the mortality by influenza is observed in the elderly and especially in this group of people the immunological response to the influenza vaccine is sub-optimal.
In principle, human influenza is a zoonosis. An influenza pandemic may occur as a result of the introduction of a new subtype of influenza A virus into the human population. At least parts of the segmented genome of the viruses that are being introduced in an "antigenic shift" are of animal origin. If such a virus manages to establish itself in the human population, drift variants of these viruses cause epidemics in the years to follow and they become human influenza viruses. In some cases, direct transmission of influenza viruses from animals may cause disease in humans. Most reports on interspecies transmission to humans are dealing with swine influenza viruses. But, as has been shown in the influenza A (H5N1) virus outbreak in Hong Kong in 1997, poultry can be the source of viruses that are transmitted directly to humans as well. However, in all these cases the viruses did not manage to spread efficiently amongst the human population. Interspecies transmission of animal influenza viruses to humans probably is a more frequent event than we know. Studies in human sera from rural China show antibodies to a variety of non-human influenza virus subtypes. In addition, the prevalence of antibodies to the avian-like swine influenza A (H1N1) viruses seem to increase with a higher exposure to pigs. This means that many asymptomatic interspecies transmissions from animal influenza viruses to humans may occur. If this happens during human influenza epidemics, a reassortant virus with pandemic potential may be generated. The influenza A (H2N2) and influenza A (H3N2) viruses that caused the 1957 and 1968 pandemics, both were reassortant viruses and contained both human- and avian-like gene segments. Therefore, human influenza surveillance should not only focus on the identification of antigenic drift variants of human influenza viruses. More attention should be paid to the frequency of transmission of animal influenza viruses to humans.
Interspecies transmission of influenza viruses: the host range barriers
Yoshihiro Kawaoka
School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2015 Linden Drive West, Madison, WI 53706, USA
Ample evidence suggests that all influenza viruses in mammals were likely derived from those in wild waterfowl at some time. In addition to those already established in mammals, the viruses have been transmitted to both mammals and to poultry from wild waterfowl and caused outbreaks in recent years. Experimentally, however, the viruses from one species of animals do not grow efficiently in other species. For example, human influenza viruses do not replicate in ducks or in horses, indicating their host range restriction. In my talk, I will review the current knowledge on the host range restriction of influenza viruses, focusing on the role of the hemagglutinin (HA).
HA is one of the major determinants of host range restriction, because of its role in host cell recognition. The receptor specificity of influenza viruses varies depending on the host animals from which they are isolated. Human influenza viruses preferentially recognize sialyloligosaccharides terminated by N-acetyl sialic acid linked to galactose by the 2,6 linkage (NeuAc 2,6Gal), whereas avian and equine viruses recognize N-acetyl sialic acid linked to galactose by the 2,3 linkage (NeuAc 2,3Gal).
Correspondingly, predominant sialic acid-galactose linkages of sialyloligosaccharides in epithelial cells at the viral replication sites differ depending on the host species.
For example, epithelial cells in human trachea contain mainly NeuAc 2,6Gal, whereas those in horse trachea and duck intestine (where avian viruses replicate) contain mainly NeuAc 2,3Gal linkages. Interestingly, epithelial cells in pig trachea contain both NeuAc 2,6Gal and NeuAc 2,3Gal linkages, explaining the high susceptibility of this animal to both human and avian influenza viruses. Thus, host specificities of influenza viruses could be affected by the abundance of these two types of sialic acid-galactose linkages in sialyloligosaccharides on the cell surface.
Even though there is a difference in predominant sialyloligosaccharides at the replication site of influenza viruses among different host animals, the 1997 Hong Kong outbreak demonstrated that avian influenza viruses can be transmitted directly to humans. In my talk, I will present data indicating that the extent of host range restriction determined by HA receptor specificity depends on the host animals and virus strains involved.
Interspecies transmission of influenza viruses: a Hong Kong perspective
K.F. Shortridge and collaborators
Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
Influenza is a natural infection of certain animals particularly aquatic birds in which the virus lives asymptomatically in the intestine. In contrast, the virus can cause severe infections of economic importance in domestic, land-based birds. Humans seemingly are irrelevant to the virus's survival, yet irregularly occurring zoonotic transmission is thought to give rise to human influenza pandemics. All pandemics including the H3N2 (Hong Kong) pandemic of 1968 have occurred without warning. After that pandemic, it was the aspiration to have in place an early warning system that would recognize an incipient pandemic in humans and so blunt its effect. A higher aspiration was to recognize the virus in animals, the hypothetical source of the virus, before it appeared in humans.
The occurrence of influenza viruses in certain animals, agricultural practices that facilitate transmission of influenza viruses between animals and humans, the origin of the H3N2 and the H2N2 (Asian) pandemic virus of 1957 and historical records identified in 1982 southern China as a hypothetical influenza epicentre in which this event would most likely occur.
In August 1997, influenza H5N1 virus was isolated from a child who died in May on the heels of a H5N1 influenza outbreak of high mortality in chicken in Hong Kong. In November and December, a further 17 cases of H5N1 influenza of which 5 were fatal, occurred in apparently haphazard fashion suggesting avian-to-human rather than human-to-human transmission. Virus surveillance of a wide range of animals indicated major market poultry as the source of the virus; chicken, of which about one-fifth were infected, and less so ducks and geese, giving rise to an excessive H5N1 virus 'load' upon the Hong Kong community.
Genetic studies indicate that the H5N1 virus is a reassortant 'avian' influenza virus that was rapidly evolving in Hong Kong poultry markets.
It possessed 'human specific' consensus amino acid sequences previously found in internal proteins of human strains which may be important in zoonotic transmission. This information vindicates on genetic grounds the slaughter of chicken and other poultry as the source of virus for humans.
During the H5N1 incident, H9N2 viruses were isolated from duck, geese, pigeon, quail, chicken (4.9%) and market environmental swabs. The virus appears to be widespread in chicken in Asia and may have been the donor of the 'internal' genes of the virus responsible for the H5N1 incident in Hong Kong in 1997.
Hong Kong recognized the signs of an incipient influenza pandemic in humans and its immediate source in chicken. It reacted vigorously and timely and may have averted a full-blown pandemic. This does not preclude the possibility that the virus is still present in a non-human host in the region or beyond.
In February 1999, H5N1 virus was isolated from the faeces of geese imported into Hong Kong. Its H5 gene was almost identical to that of the 1997 H5 virus, the other seven genes being more closely related to those of avian influenza viruses of the 70's and 80's.
The isolation of H5N1 viruses in 1999 upholds the policy of having segregated wholesale poultry markets in Hong Kong, one for chicken and other land-based birds, the other for ducks and geese which are killed inside the market.
The intriguing question is - why was the 1997 H5N1 virus in Hong Kong pathogenic for humans as well as chicken while elsewhere H5 viruses are apparently pathogenic for land-based poultry only?
Genetic analysis of host-specificity determinants within the transcription/replication complex of influenza A viruses
N. Naffakh, P. Massin, C. Quémin, N. Escriou, B. Crescenzo-Chaigne and S. van der Werf
Unit of Molecular Genetics of Respiratory Viruses, URA 1966 CNRS, Institut Pasteur, Paris, France
Introduction
Generally, avian influenza viruses do not replicate efficiently or cause disease in humans. However, the pandemic viruses isolated in 1957 and 1968 were found to derive their gene segments from both human and avian viruses. Avian virus segments encoded not only the surface glycoproteins (NA and/or HA) but also the RNA polymerase PB1. More recently, human infection with an avian influenza virus (A/HongKong/156/97) was reported in Hong-Kong (1,2), thus stressing the need for a better understanding of the molecular basis of host specificity among influenza viruses. We addressed the question of wether the proteins involved in the replication process were determinant in host-specificity, by making use of the genetic system for the in vivo reconstitution of active synthetic influenza virus-like ribonucleoproteins described by Pleshka et al. (3).
Material and methods
Molecular cloning of cDNAs: Viral RNA was extracted from the A/FPV/Rostock/34 (Rostock), A/Mallard/NY/78 (Mallard), and A/HongKong/156/97 (HK) viral isolates grown in 11 day-old embryonated chicken eggs (Rostock, Mallard) or on MDCK cells (HK). Full-length cDNAs were prepared by reverse transcription of viral RNA using a primer complementary to the 12bp conserved at the 3' end of each viral segment, and subsequently amplified using primers specific of each PB1, PB2, PA or NP gene. Double stranded cDNAs were then cloned into the EcoRV site of the pHMG plasmid vector (3), and their sequence was determined. The cDNAs derived from A/PR/8/34 (PR8) and A/Victoria/3/75 (Victoria) viruses were kindly provided by J. Pavlovic and A. Portela, respectively.
Transient replication assay: The pPOLI-CAT-RT plasmid (3), designed to allow expression of an artificial viral RNA-like transcript, was kindly provided by P. Palese. A mixture of pHMG-PB1, -PB2, -PA, -NP (1;1;1;2mg) and pPOLI-CAT-RT (1mg) plasmids was transfected into COS-1 cells, using the Fugen-mediated method (Boehringer Mannheim). After 48hrs of incubation at 37°C, cells were harvested and cell extracts tested for CAT activity, using the CAT ELISA Kit (Boehringer Mannheim).
Click here to see Fig. 1: Effect of the human (PR8)/avian (Rostock or HK) origin of PB2 and role of PB2 amino acid 627 on the activity of the indicated chimeric replication complexes. For each combination CAT activity is expressed as the % of the CAT activity obtained with PR8.
Results
All 16 possible combinations between human (PR8 or Victoria) and avian (Rostock, Mallard or HK)-derived pHMG-PB1, -PB2, -PA and -NP plasmids were transfected together with plasmid pPOLI-CAT-RT into COS-1 cells. The efficiency with which the various reconstituted heterospecific complexes were able to direct replication of the artificial RNA segment was determined by measuring the CAT activity in the transfected cells.
For any given combination of PB1, PA and NP of human or avian virus origin, the CAT activity was higher when PB2 was derived from a human virus. However, when PB2 from Rostock or Mallard viruses with a Glu-->Lys substitution of amino acid 627 were used, levels of
CAT activity similar to those achieved with PR8-PB2 were obtained (Fig. 1). For any given combination of PB2, PA and NP derived from a human or an avian virus, CAT activity was higher (up to 100 fold) when PB1 was derived from the avian virus (Fig. 2). Furthermore, whatever the combination between PB1, PB2 and PA, the CAT activity was higher when NP was derived from the same virus as PB2. Homospecificity between PA and PB2 also appeared to enhance the efficiency of some chimeric replication complexes.
Click here to see Fig. 2: Effect of the human/avian origin of PB1 on the indicated replication complexes. Expression of CAT activity is as in Fig 1.
In such experiments, PB2, PB1 and PA proteins from the HK virus were found to behave in an intermediate fashion with respect to human and avian viruses. Indeed, as compared to Rostock or Mallard proteins, both the disadvantage of HK-PB2 over PR8-PB2 and the advantage of HK-PB1 over PR8-PB1 were reduced in a number of combinations (Figs 1&2), whereas the compatibility of HK-PA with PR8 or Victoria derived proteins seemed to be increased.
Discussion
Our results allowed the identification of PB2 amino acid 627 as a major determinant of the efficiency of the influenza A virus replication complex in mammalian cells, in accordance with previously published observations on reassortant viruses (4).
Moreover they suggest : 1) that acquisition of the PB1 segment from an avian virus could confer a selective advantage to reassortant viruses such as those involved in the 1957 and 1968 pandemics; 2) that PB2-PA and PB2-NP interactions could contribute to the stabilization of the replication complex and may therefore impose some limits on reassortment events that involve the corresponding gene segments; 3) that some molecular characteristics of PB1, PB2 and PA proteins could partially account for the pathogenicity of A/HK/156/97 virus in humans.
References
1. de Jong, J.C., Claas, E.C.J., Osterhaus, A.D.M.E., Webster, R.G. and Lim, W.L. (1997) A pandemic warning Nature 389: 554
2. Subbarao, K., Klimov, A., Katz, J., Regnery, H. et al. (1998) Characterization of an avian Influenza A (H5N1) virus isolated from a child with a fatal respiratory illness. Science, 279: 393-396.
3. Pleshka, S., Jaskunas, S.R., Engelhardt, O.G., Zürcher, T., Palese, P. and Garcia-Sastre A. et al. (1996) A plasmid-based reverse genetics system for Influenza A virus. J. Virol., 70: 4188-4192.
4. Subbarao, K., London, W. and Murphy, B.R. (1993) A single amino-acid in the PB2 gene of Influenza A virus is a determinant of host range. J. Virol., 67: 1761-1764.
Domains of PB2 conferring plaquing ability for an avian influenza virus in mammalian cell lines.
Y. Yongxiu*, J. McCauley# , J.W. Almond* and W.S. Barclay*.
*School of Animal and Microbial Sciences, University of Reading and #Institute of Animal Health, Compton, U.K.
Introduction
The avian influenza virus FPV Rostock does not form plaques in mouse L cells. A host range mutant of FPV Dobson, a virus closely related to FPV Rostock, was selected by multiple passage in mammalian cell types including L cells, HeLa cells and BHK cells. This virus, known as Dobson 4H, forms clear plaques in L cells. Previous work with reassortant viruses showed that the plaquing phenotype was conferred by segment 1 RNA which encodes the PB2 subunit of the viral polymerase complex (1). We are attempting to understand the molecular basis of this host range restriction as it may provide important clues as to the events which precede zoonotic transmission of avian influenza viruses into mammalian hosts.
Results
We have cloned and sequenced the entire segment 1 RNA of the Dobson 4H mutant and compared the sequence with that from the parental strain Dobson and with the published sequence of Rostock PB2. We identified 10 sequence differences between the 4H mutant and the progenitor strain. We postulate that three of these contribute to the plaquing phenotype since they are different in the 4H virus from both Rostock and Dobson parental viruses. These changes shown in bold are all located in the carboxy terminal domain of the PB2 protein (Table 1).
Table 1. Differences of proteins sequences between Dobson 4H, Dobson and Rostock FPV.
|
Amino Acid |
482 |
647 |
701 |
|
Dobson 4H |
R |
M |
N |
|
Dobson |
K |
I |
D |
|
Rostock |
K |
I |
D |
We sought to confirm this hypothesis by introducing segment 1 of the Dobson 4H mutant into the Rostock genome using the technique of reverse genetics. This allows us to engineer specific changes into the influenza genome, and thus precisely investigate sequence changes in PB2 which allow productive infection in mammalian cells by FPV Rostock. We reconstituted RNP complexes from synthetic RNAs derived from the Dobson 4H cDNA or from a chimeric cDNA encoding a PB2 with Rostock amino terminus and Dobson 4H carboxy domain. The RNPs were introduced into CEF or MDBK cells and the progeny viruses were passaged in L cells to select those which contained PB2 genes which allow plaque formation on L cells. We rescued viruses with whole Dobson 4H segment 1 in a Rostock genome background, and also some Rostock mutants which had acquired host range mutations.
The mechanism by which differences in the PB2 gene of avian influenza viruses alter the host range phenotype is still unknown. Previous reports have suggested that FPV Rostock is inhibited from forming plaques in mammalian cells because of an aberrant production of certain viral proteins (2;3). Viral proteins derived from spliced messages seem to be produced in excess, and those derived from the unspliced message are present in lower than normal amounts. A deficiency of M1 and excess of NS2 might result in poor transport of vRNP from the nucleus late in infection (4). We have investigated cellular localization of viral proteins after infection of avian or mammalian cells with the Dobson 4H or Rostock virus in an attempt to understand the intracellular events which are blocked.
Discussion
The reason why changes in the PB2 protein might rescue the plaquing ability of an avian virus in mammlian cell lines is still unclear. PB2 is an integral part of the viral polymerase complex. Shih and Krug have suggested that binding of the viral polymerase to the promoter late in infection may regulate splicing, and have also shown that splicing is dependent on host cell proteins (5;6). It is conceivable that changes in PB2 sequences which affect the affinity of the polymerase complex for the RNA can compensate for a deficiency in splicing regulation in cells which lack or are deficient in certain host cell factors. These hypotheses are under investigation.
References
1. Almond, J.W.. (1977). A single gene determines the host range of influenza virus. Nature 270: 617-618.
2. Inglis, S.C. and Brown, C.M.. (1984). Differences in the control of virus mRNA splicing during permissive or abortive infection with influenza A (Fowl Plague) virus. J. Gen. Virol. 65: 153-164.
3. Lau, S.C. and Scholtisseck, C.. (1995). Abortive infection of Vero cells by an influenza A virus (FPV). Virology 212:225-231.
4. ONeill, R.E., Talon, J. and Palese P. (1998). The influenza virus NEP (NS2 protein) mediates the nuclear export of viral ribonucleoproteins. EMBO J. 17:288-296.
5. Shih, S.R., Nemeroff, N.E., and Krug, R.M. (1995). The choice of alternative 5 splice sites in influenza virus M1 mRNA is regulated by the viral polymerase complex. Proc. Natl. Acad. USA. 92: 6324-6328.
6. Shih, S.R. and Krug, R.M. (1996). Novel exploitation of a nuclear function by influenza virus: the cellular SF2/ASF splicing factor controls the amount of the essential viral M2 ion channel protein in infected cells. EMBO J. 15: 5415-5427.
Birds as reservoirs and disseminators of influenza virus genes: an ecologic approach
C. Hannoun
Institut Pasteur , Paris, 18 Villa Prévost, 92120, Montrouge, France
Introduction
Hemagglutinating viruses have been isolated by egg inoculation from several animal species: swine, horse, birds and were later found to be similar to human influenza viruses. Surface proteins are similar to those of human viruses and they can be classified in the same serotypes: H and N, whatever is the origin of the strains. This does not mean that these viruses are exactly similar: there are differences in physical properties (resistance to heat and to pH), or in their pathogenic properties (they are usually very species specific). From 1971, a universal classification system has been utilized: 15 HA and 9 NA. A virus is described by a double serotype: HxNx. In addition, isolates of the same group of viruses were obtained from other species, whether from healthy or sick animals (whale, mink, seal, dog, cat,...).
Birds play a very special role
- They host all known serotypes when other species have only a few.
- They can be highly pathogenic, but most of them are not.
- Bird viruses multiply in the intestine as well as in the respiratory tract and they are transmitted also by fecal-oral route.
A survey was undertaken since 1976 in order to investigate the presence and the circulation of influenza viruszes in wild bird populations in the North of France
Material and Methods
Wild birds, mostly ducks and other water birds were captured by a team of experienced ornithologists in the frame of a programme of study of migrations. The ornithological reserve, located in the estuary of the Somme river hosts a mixture of resident and migratory birds belongind to several species. Cloacal swab samples were taken to birds which were individually identified to be recognized if recaptured later. Samples were put in transport medium containing antibiotics and brought to the laboratory for inoculation to eggs for the isolation of virus. After proper incubation, harvested allantoic fluids were examined for the presence of hemagglutination and positive samples were subpassaged and the agent was identified by hemagglutination and neuraminidase inhibition (1) using reference sera for all types of influenza viruses.
Results
Studies in Northern France since 1976 have produced a large number of isolations in a single place over the years (2). In the present survey, 176 strains of hemagglutinating viruses were obtained, including 93 influenza viruses, 50 parainfluenza and 33 non fully identified influenza strains. The isolates (Table 1) include a wide range of serotypes (8 out of 15 HA and 6 out of 9 NA), especially from ducks and other water fowl. The serotypes are not always the same year after year, even from samples taken on the same day: some are dominant during one season and can disappear the next. The infected birds are migratory or sedentary healthy animals belonging to several species, with a majority of mallards, shellducks and pintails.
Table 1. Hemagglutinins and Neuraminidases isolated from birds
(Bay of Somme River, France 1976-1985)
|
H1 |
N1 |
|
H2 |
N2 |
|
H3 |
N4 |
|
H4 |
N5 |
|
H6 |
N8 |
|
H7 |
N9 |
|
H8 |
. . |
|
H11 |
. . |
An interesting finding was the occurrence of strains difficult to identify and for a few of them, cloning of the viral population was performed by plaque selection. Lysis plaques on MDCK cells, on which these viruses grow easily, were picked individually from early passages and each clone was re-identified. The results with a characteristic isolate is shown in Table 1. Out of 34 clones, the identification of hemagglutinin and neuraminidase serotypes was distributed into 4 categories associating H6, H7, N2 and N4 in all 4 possible combinations. This isolate contained a mixture of two different viruses and the result is a reassortment similar as those that can be obtained experimentally by inoculation of a mixture of viruses.
Table 2. 34 clones from the isolate influenza MB81
|
H7N2 |
9 |
|
H6N2 |
20 |
|
H7N4 |
1 |
|
H6N4 |
4 |
Anas platyrynchos (1976)
Distribution of serotypes
|
H6 = 24/34 |
H7 = 10/34 |
|
N2 = 29/34 |
N4 = 5/34 |
Discussion and conclusions
The results show
1- A high rate of isolation, meaning a high incidence of feral state, up to 12% in wild animals of different species and 60% in semi-captive mallards. In the latter case, virus was also isolated repeatedly from the pond in which the ducks were living.
2- However, the presence of virus is related to the time of the year, the highest rates being obtained shortly after the return from northern migration in October. Afterwards, the incidence decreases and no isolations were obtained after January.
3- The infected animals are quite healthy and were recaptured in the following weeks. Some remain positive during 15 days at least.
4- There are possibilities of recombinations since in two instances at least, mixtures of viruses were obtained from the same sample and all combinations of serotypes could be demonstrated in the mixture.
In conclusion, these observations confirm and reinforce the concept of the role of birds as a permanent reservoir of genes maintaining the virus for long periods of time. They can transport these genes on long distances and contribute to the dissemination of influenza before transspecies reassortments and eventual transmission to man. This is an important aspect of the ecology of influenza viruses and has important consequences on the human epidemiology since the transfer of influenza virus genes from avian strains to human strains is generally recognized to be the cause of the appearance of pandemic strains in human populations (3).
References
(1) Fiszon,B. & Hannoun C.(1990), Comparison of neuraminidases of the same type but different species using a new method of titration.. J.Virol.Meth., 27, 79-90.
(2) Hannoun,C. & Devaux,J.M.(1980), Circulation enzootique permanente de virus grippaux dans la baie de la Somme. Comp.Immun.Microbiol.. Infect.Dis., 3, 177-183.
(3) Webster, R.G., Hinshaw V.S., Bean, W.J., Turner,B. & Shortridge,K.F. (i977), Influenza viruses from avian and porcine sources and their possible rôle in the origin of human pandemic strains. Biol Standard. 39, 461-468.
A summary of studies on influenza virus, H10N4 and H10N7, of avian origin in mink
L. Englund1 and B. Klingeborn2
1Department of Small Animals, National Veterinary Institute, Box 7073, S-750 07 Uppsala (Sweden), 2Department of Virology, National Veterinary Institute, Biomedical Centre, Box 585, S-751 23 Uppsala (Sweden)
Introduction
Avian influenza virus sometimes cross the species-barrier from birds to mammalian species, including man. Occasionally this infection causes clinical disease which increases the probability of virus detection. When the influenza virus crosses over to a domestic species previously unaffected by influenza-like disease it is likely that the "new disease" will come to the attention of a diagnostic laboratory. This is what happened in 1984 when a six-week outbreak of a severe respiratory disease caused a three-fold increase of the expected mortality rate in 33 mink farms (1).
Materials and methods
Necropsies were performed on 46 mink which died following symptoms of severe respiratory distress. Lung tissue samples were submitted for histopathology, virology and bacteriology.
The influenza virus isolates from the field were serologically suptyped by HI and NI tests. Convalescent sera during the outbreak as well as 2,891 serum samples collected five months later were analysed by HI-test or ELISA for antibodies to A/mink/Sweden/84 virus.
The entire genomes of three H10N4 viruses, isolated from mink (Sweden, 1984), mallard, and fowl (both UK, 1985) were genetically compared by oligonucleotide mapping.
Experimental infection of mink was initially used to link the isolated influenza virus to the clinical symptoms and pathological lesions observed from the field outbreak. In a subsequent study, mink were infected intranasally with mink/84, mallard/85, fowl/85, or chicken/49 (2) to compare clinical symtoms, antibody response, and possible in-contact transmission. Experimental aerosol infections of mink, using mink/84 or chicken/49, were then used to compare in more detail the pathogenesis of the two virus infections. Measurements of daily weight gain and area density of pneumonia in lung sections were compared using the two-tailed unpaired Students t-test.
Results
Interstitial pneumonia was observed in a majority of the necropsied mink from the field outbreak. Six antigenically identical isolates of influenza A virus of subtype H10N4 (mink/84) were recovered. Convalescent sera during the outbreak as well as more than 50% of the sera collected five months later in the affected farms were positive for antibodies to mink/84 virus, while no antibodies or virus could be detected in samples from unaffected farms. Interstingly, all convalescent sera were also positive for antibodies to the two concomitantly circulating human H3N2 strains (1, 3).
Oligonucleotide mapping of the whole genomes showed a very high (ª 98%) sequence homology between mink/84 and mallard/85 and fowl/85, respectively (4). Together with phylogenetic studies of nucleoprotein genes of avian and mammalian influenza viruses (5) this strongly indicates the direct avian origin of mink/84.
Following intranasal infection of mink, all three H10N4 isolates, i.e. mink/84, mallard/85 and fowl/85, caused respiratory disease, interstitial pneumonia, specific antibody production and were transmitted via contact infection. The most consistent disease signs were seen with mink/84. Chicken/49 (H10N7) did not cause clinical disease or contact infection, but induced antibody production and mild lung lesions (4).
Further comparison between mink/84 and chicken/49 revealed that the infections progressed in similar patterns over the first 24 hours post infection but from 48 hours post infection obvious differences were recorded. Whereas in mink infected with chicken/49 no disease signs were observed, the inflammatory pulmonary lesions remained focal and presence of viral antigen sparse, the mink infected with mink/84 showed severe signs of respiratory disease, with inflammatory lesions spreading throughout the lung and viral antigen present in substantial numbers of cells in the lung, nasal mucosa, and trachea. The subjective observations were supported by the facts that the mean daily weight gain was significantly lower (p<0.001), while the median area densities of pneumonia were significantly higher (p=0.043) for the mink/84 group than for the chicken/49 group (6).
Discussion
Our studies show that mink is a species capable of picking up and transmitting certain avian influenza virus strains. Since farmed mink are also sometimes infected by human influenza virus strains, as shown in serological surveys, the possible role of mink as mixing vessels for strains of avian and human influenza must not be ignored.
In this case the avian influenza virus (A/mink/Sweden/84, H10N4) was highly pathogenic for mink as well as contagious, but did not remain in the mink population. One reason could be the production structure which caused the annual culling of >80% of the mink population for fur production some weeks after the influenza outbreak, saving only adult breeding stock, thus diminishing the population at risk and minimizing the population density.
These results show that respiratory disease in mammalian species should be analysed for influenza virus of avian origin. An increased awareness of influenza virus as a possible cause of disease in previously unaffected species is necessary to detect any cross-species infections, which could subsequently present a threat to the human population.
References
1. Klingeborn, B., Englund, L., Rott, R., Juntti, N., and Rockborn, G. (1985) An avian influenza virus killing a mammalian species - the mink. Arch. Virol., 86:347-351.
2. Dinter, Z. (1949) Eine variante des virus des Geflügelpest in Bayern? Tierärtzl. Umchau, 4:185-186.
3. Englund, L., Klingeborn, B., and Mejerland, T. (1986) Avian influenza virus causing an outbreak of contageous interstitial pneumonia in mink. Acta vet. Scand., 27:497-504.
4. Berg, M., Englund, L., Abusugra, I.A., Klingeborn, B., and Linné, T. (1990) Close relationship between mink influenza (H10N4) and concomitantly circulating avian influenza viruses. Arch. Virol., 113:61-71.
5. Gammelin, M., Altmüller, A., Reinhardt, U., Mandler, J., Harley, V.R., Hudson, P.J., Fitch, W.M., and Scholtissek, C. (1990) Phylogenetic analysis of nucleoproteins suggests that human influenza A viruses emerged from a 19th-century avian ancestor. Mol. Biol. Evol., 7(2):194-200.
6. Englund, L. and Hård af Segerstad, C. (1998) Two avian H10 influenza A virus strains with different pathogenicity for mink (Mustela vison). Arch. Virol., 143:653-666.
Antigenic community between neuraminidase from A/H5NI and the 1918 influenza pandemic
L. Gérentes, M. Aymard, and N.Kessler
National Influenza Centre, Laboratory of virology, 8 Avenue Rockefeller 69373 Lyon cedex 08 France
Introduction
The introduction of an avian A/H5N1 influenza virus (A/HK/156/97) in the human population in May 1997 in Hong-Kong, and the following identification of subsequent cases in November and December, was alarming ; indeed, the lack of protective immunity in the human beings against a new HA or a new NA can result in rapid spread of the virus, and it was reasonable to ask the question of how likely was a pandemic. Being faced with such a situation, we were interested to evaluate the serological status of the French population against the A/HK/156/97 strain
Materials
Viruses : Three different influenza viruses were used : A/PR/8/34 and A/Texas/36/91 viruses were produced by inoculation of embryonated hens eggs. A/HK/156/97 H5N1 strain was isolated and then produced in MDCK cells
Human sera :1) Fifty nine paired sera were collected during winter seasons 1994-1995, 1995-1996, in a home for the aged, 34 pairs (71-98 years) were obtained from elderly people (mean age 80 years) and 25 pairs from adult staff members (24-60 years). All of them were vaccinated annually from the start of their stay/work in the home, with a trivalent inactivated, containing A/Texas H1N1.
2) Eighty two sera were randomly collected from blood donors (36-69 years)
Due to the fact that A/H1N1 virus was responsible for two pandemics during the twentieth Century, (1918, 1934) all 200 sera we collected for this study, were ranged in groups of age corresponding to people that potentially met : (i) the two pandemics, 1918 and 1934 (76-98 years old people), (ii) the sole 1934 pandemic (60-75 years old people) and (iii) no pandemic (20-59 years old people)
Methods
Hemagglutinin inhibition test (HI) was done in microtiter plates as described by Palmer et al (1975) using hen red blood cells.
Neuraminidase inhibition test procedure (NI) was performed according to Aymard-Henry et al (1973) using fetuin as substrate.
Virus neutralisation test (Nt) were done in MDCK cells by Tobita et al (1975)
Results
1)Antigenic characterisation of A/HK/156/97 H5N1 NA. The NA of A/HK/ H5N1 virus was characterized in NI test using specific post infection antisera from ferret. (i) The H5N1 NA cross reacted with the four ferrets anti sera which were directed against the swine influenza strains. (ii) No antigenic relationship could be detected between the NA of A/HK virus and that of the human A/H1N1 influenza strains (A/PR8 and A/Texas)
2) Distribution of anti-A/HK/156/97 H5N1 HI Abs in human sera. All human sera were tested in HI test using A/HK/ H5N1 virus. Among the 200 sera tested, 198 were found to be devoid of HI Abs and two of them exhibited a very low HI titre (10). These two weakly positive sera were eliminated from the serum panel we used thereafter.
3) Distribution of anti-A/HK/156/97 H5N1 NI Abs in human sera. All the 198 remaining human sera were tested in NI against the A/H5N1 strain, and two different A/H1N1 strains, the prevalence of NI positive sera was expressed as a function of both antigen and age : (i) the first profile obtained with A/HK and A/PR8 showed a very high prevalence (³ 80 %) of NI positive sera in the two age groups corresponding to persons > 60 years old, when a very low prevalence was found in the third group (< 59 years old). (ii) The second profile obtained with A/Texas differed from the one described above in terms of NI positive Ab prevalence in the two age groups corresponding to persons <76 years ; indeed the prevalence increased significantly in the youngest age group (20-59 years) while it decreased significantly in the medium age group (60-75 years old).
Such an analysis of NI Ab prevalence in human sera as a function of age of patients and A/H1N1 virus used in NI test, suggested a close antigenic relationship between NA of both A/HK and A/PR8 viruses when A/Texas NA looked significantly different. As a consequence we have no longer introduced the A/Texas strain in the following experiments.
4) Distribution of anti-A/HK/156/97 neutralizing Abs in human sera.
Demonstrating in human sera the existence of NI Abs in absence of any HI Abs gave us an excellent opportunity to search for the neutralizing potential of anti-A/HK anti-NA Abs.
The prevalence of anti-A/HK Nt Abs was calculated by age groups and then was compared with that of either anti- A/HK/ NI Abs or anti A/PR8 NI Abs (figure 1). Two observations emerged from such a comparison : (i) Inside each age group, a similar ratio between anti A/HK Nt Ab frequency and either anti A/HK NI Ab or anti A/PR8 NI Ab frequencies. (ii) As a function of the age group, the frequency ratio between Nt Abs and NI Abs (anti A/HK and anti PR8 as well) was shown highly different. While a similar NI Ab prevalence (80%) (anti- A/HK and anti-A/PR8 as well) was found in both 60-75 and 76-98 years age groups, anti A/HK Nt Ab prevalence were found highly different, 26 % versus 70 %. As a consequence Nt to NI Ab ratios were found 0.33 and 0.80 in 60-75 and 76-98 age groups respectively. Due to the very low frequency of anti A/HK N1 Abs in the 20-59 year age group, results regarding Nt/NI frequency ratio could not be considered as interpretable.
The differences, we observed between 60-75 and 76-98 year age groups when comparing Nt and NI Ab frequency were conforted when plotting, in each age group, Nt versus NI Ab titres (i) a > 20 NI titre value was most often associated with the presence of neutralizing Abs. (ii) an increase in NI titre was accompanied by a parallel increase in the Nt titre. Such an analysis of the prevalence by age of anti- A/HK Nt and NI Abs respectively showed without any ambiguity that the 76-98 year old persons represent the sole age group exhibiting a similar distribution of these two categories of Abs.
Discussion
The observation was made when introducing the 198 sera lacking anti-A/HK/156/97 HI Abs in the NI test against A/HK virus and then when analysing the results as a function of the age groups, we previously established on the basis of the opportunity people have had to meet the 1918 and /or the 1934 influenza pandemic strains. Indeed, an unexpected high prevalence of anti-A/HK NI Abs was found in sera from persons ranging in the two age groups 59-75 and 76-98 years when a low prevalence was found in sera from persons <59 years.
The close similarity between the profiles of anti-A/HK and anti-A/PR8 NI Ab prevalence by age group suggested a close antigenic relationship between the NA of these two viruses.
Numerous human sera were found capable to neutralize the infectivity of A/HK virus in vitro, mainly those belonging to the 76-98 years age group. As a consequence Nt Ab prevalence was highly correlated with NI Ab prevalence (anti-A/HK and anti-A/PR8 as well) in this group, inversely to what was observed in the 60-75 years age group. From these informations it was reasonable to assume that (i) in the 60-75 years age group, pre-existing NI Abs likely directed to A/PR8 virus, were capable to inhibit the enzymatic activity of the A/HK virus, but cannot neutralize efficiently virus infectivity, (ii) in the 76-98 years age group pre-existing NI Abs likely directed to the 1918 pandemic strain were capable to inhibit the enzymatic activities of both A/PR8 and A/HK virus strains and also to neutralize the infectivity of A/HK virus.
In this study, the elimination of the possible role of anti-HA Abs afforded us the possibility to approach the protective role of anti-NA Abs by demonstrating the neutralizing potency of the laters.
Our data bring serological arguments for the close antigenic relationship between the NA of the A/HK and that of the 1918 pandemic H1N1 strain. Such an antigenic community between these two neuraminidases agree with what we know about their nucleotide sequence. In addition, Yuen et al., (1998) and Class et al. (1998) suggested that the H1N1 virus responsible for the human pandemic of the 1918 may have been a direct introduction of an avian virus into human beings.
Structural changes of the (avian) influenza virus hemagglutinin which influence virulence.
Michael L. Perdue
Southeast Poultry Research Lab, 934 College Station Road, Athens, USA
Analysis of the structure of the avian influenza (AI) virus hemagglutinin (HA) gene and protein has yielded a wealth of information on the virulence mechanisms of influenza viruses. The AI hemagglutinin appears to be unique in its capacity to accept basic amino acids at its proteolytic cleavage site (PCS). The association of multiple basic (MB) amino acids, tissue spread and virulence by AI strains first proposed by Klenk, Rott, Orlich and others in the late 1970s has held fast for over two decades now. While other structural characteristics and other genes can certainly influence virulence, the presence of the MB amino acids at the PCS has provided a hallmark structural feature which justifies continuing sequence analysis of emerging field isolates of AI strains. In addition to this structural feature, the distal tip of the HA is prone to appearance and disappearance of glycosylation sites, some of which have been associated with virulence. In our laboratory, for example it was shown that presence of a carbohydrate near the receptor binding site (RBS) of an H7 AI isolate was associated with increased virulence in chickens.
The H5N1 viruses which emerged in Hong Kong in 1997 were unique both in structure of their HA protein and pathology in animals. These chicken viruses contained multiple basic amino acids at the cleavage site and a mutable carbohydrate addition site at the tip of the receptor binding site. They were highly lethal in chickens but unlike other highly pathogenic AI strains they were also lethal in mice. Thus these viruses have provided an ideal model system with which to study the structural features of the HA of a highly virulent virus.
The importance of the structural features of the HA in the recent outbreaks in Mexico, Australia, Hong Kong and in the ongoing outbreak of H7 avian influenza in the northeast United States, as delineated by our laboratory will be summarized. The structure of the avian influenza hemagglutinin is a continually changing landscape and following and characterizing these changes remains an important challenge.
Characterisation of a non-pathogenic H5N1(A/ty/Eng/87-92/91) isolate with multiple basic amino acids at the HA cleavage site
J. Banks, E. C. Speidel, D. J. Alexander.
VLA Weybridge, Addlestone, UK.
Introduction
Two H5N1 viruses were isolated from a single turkey during an outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) in Norfolk, England in 1991. One (A/ty/Eng/50-92/91) is highly pathogenic for domestic poultry, has multiple basic amino acids at the haemagglutinin (HA) cleavage site and grows well in MDCK cells without the addition of trypsin, characteristics typical of HPAI viruses. The other (A/ty/Eng/87-92/91) has the same HA cleavage site, but is not pathogenic and does not grow in MDCK cells even with the addition of trypsin. The two isolates do not have any sequence differences in the haemagglutinin (HA) gene which correlate with virulence (1). This study investigates the growth and molecular characteristics of a limiting dilution passage clone of A/ty/Eng/87-92/91 (LDP3).
Materials and Methods
Two groups of ten 3-4-week old specific pathogen free leghorn chickens were inoculated with 106 EID50 of freshly harvested LDP3 virus, one group intranasally and the other group by the intravenous route. One-day post infection (PI) six uninoculated birds were placed in contact. Cloacal and tracheal swabs were taken daily for 10 days, and one bird from each inoculated group was killed from days 3-11. Eight organ samples were taken from each bird at sacrifice (kidney, pancreas, lung, heart, brain, spleen, intestine, and trachea). Virus isolation was attempted from the samples by three passages in 9 or 10-day-old embryonating fowls eggs. Brain tissues were tested by nested RT/PCR for evidence of H5 influenza virus. The experiment was repeated using 3-4-week old turkeys.
Fourteen-day-old embryonating fowls eggs were inoculated with the avian influenza isolate LDP3. Allantoic fluids were harvested after 48 hours incubation at 37oC and screened for growth on confluent MDCK monolayers without the addition of trypsin. Parental virus LDP3 was included as a control. Each culture was sampled daily and tested for HA activity. Selected cultures positive by HA were passaged in MDCK cells and 11-day-old embryonating fowls eggs. Two isolates (G33 and B22) were selected for sequencing of the entire HA gene. The entire PB2 gene for isolates G33, LDP3 and clone 2L was sequenced and partially sequenced for A/ty/Eng/50-92/91 clones 3L, 5L, and 87v from A/ty/Eng/87-92/91. The neuraminidase (NA) gene was sequenced for LDP3 and 2L. An IVPI was determined for clone G33 in 6-week-old white leghorn chickens
Results
Chickens and turkeys infected with clone LDP3 by the intranasal or by the intravenous routes excreted very little virus. No clinical signs were seen and there was no transmission to in contact birds. Virus was only recovered from the kidneys of sacrificed chickens and nested RT/PCR analysis of the brains for evidence of virus was negative. This is in contrast to A/ty/Eng/50-92/91, which can be easily isolated or detected by RT/PCR from tracheal or cloacal swabs, or from organs, including the lungs, kidney and brain. All sentinel birds become infected with this virus.
Of the 128 14-day-old embryonating fowls eggs inoculated with LDP3 55 (43%) gave positive HA results in the MDCK screening assay. All MDCK isolates inoculated into 11-day-old embryonating fowls eggs were lethal to the embryos and the allantoic fluids were positive for HA activity. The second passage of 32 MDCK isolates yielded 19 HA positive cultures, the parental virus LDP3 did not initiate a productive infection on primary or second passage. An IVPI index for isolate G30 was 0 and no clinical signs were observed. Nucleotide sequencing of the HA gene for isolates G33 and B22 showed no differences from the parental LDP3 sequence. Nucleotide sequencing of the entire PB2 gene for clones LDP3, G33 and 2L and partial sequencing of clones 5L from A/ty/Eng/50-92/91and 87v from A/ty/Eng/87-92/91 did not show any amino acid changes that correlate with pathogenicity
There are no nucleotide differences between the NA genes of LDP3 and 2L but there is a deletion in the stalk region of 23 amino acids as compared with A/parrot/NI/73.
Discussion
The H5N1 isolate A/ty/Eng/87-92/91 was isolated from the brain of a turkey that had died of HPAI. However, clone LDP3 derived from this isolate is unable to disseminate throughout the body or to replicate in the brains of chickens and turkeys, as would be expected for a virus with multiple basic amino acids at the HA cleavage site. Passage in 14-day-old embryonating fowls eggs readily selects mutants from the avirulent clone LDP3 of A/ty/Eng/87-92 that can grow in MDCK cells in the absence of trypsin. This is in contrast to passage of LDP3 in chickens or 10 to 11-day-old embryonating fowls eggs, which fails to produce mutants capable of growth in MDCK. This increased measure of virulence however, did not translate to virulence in chickens, clone G30 had an IVPI of 0. No changes were seen in the HA nucleotide sequences relative to the parental LDP3 virus and therefore the selective pressure giving rise to growth in MDCK cells of mutants B22 and G33 must lie elsewhere in the genome. Reassortant experiments have led to speculation that the PB2 and Matrix genes may play a role in the modulation of pathogenicity (2). Therefore the entire PB2 gene for clones 2L G33 and LDP3 was nucleotide sequenced highlighting three deduced amino acid changes that appeared to correlate with pathogenicity. However, partial nucleotide sequencing of clones 5L, and 87v showed that there was no correlation with the deduced amino acid changes and IVPI.
Recently it has been suggested that additional glycosylation of the HA together with a shortened NA stalk are characteristic features of the H5 and H7 chicken viruses (3). Interestingly the NA genes of LDP3 and A/ty/Eng/50-92/91 have a predicted 23 amino acid deletion as compared with A/parrot/NI/73. However neither of these isolates have additional glycosylation sites on the HA thus proving to be exceptions for this rule.
This work was funded by MAFF UK.
A reverse genetics approach demonstrates that influenza virus growth is regulated by hemagglutinin glycosylation
Ralf Wagner1, Thorsten Wolff1, Astrid Herwig1, Stephan Pleschka2, and Hans-Dieter Klenk1
Introduction
Influenza virus infection is initiated by binding of virus particles to sialic acid-containing receptors on the surface of host cells. This binding function is provided by the influenza virus hemagglutinin (HA) glycoprotein. The hemagglutinin region responsible for receptor binding has been shown to involve a pocket of amino acids at the membrane distal tip of the molecule. With HA of fowl plague virus (A/FPV/Rostock/34) this binding pocket is flanked by two N-linked oligosaccharide side chains. In previous studies in which FPV-HA mutants lacking either one (mutants G1 and G2) or both (mutant G1,2) glycosylation sites were expressed from an SV40 vector we showed that these glycans modulate receptor binding affinity (1). In this study we were interested in whether these glycan depletions have an effect on the virus growth when mutated HA is stably inserted in recombinant viruses via a reverse genetics approach. In this system an influenza virus-like mutated HA segment is transcribed in the nucleus of transfected cells by cellular RNA polymerase I from a plasmid vector. Upon infection of the cells with a suitable helper virus mutated HA segments are incorporated into progeny virions. Two reassortants of A/WSN/33 were used as helper viruses to create two series of HA-mutant recombinant viruses only differing in carrying neuraminidase (NA) of either N1- or N2-subtype, respectively.
Here we show that the lack of one (mutant G2) or both glycans (mutant G1,2) has a severe effect on growth of the N1-NA-containing viruses which is mainly due to an impaired release of progeny virus from infected cells. For N2-NA viruses such growth restrictions were not detectable with the G2 mutant and much less apparent with the G1,2 mutant. Our results indicate that interactions between the receptor binding site and adjacent oligo-saccharides of HA are crucial for the potential of influenza viruses to grow in host cells.
Materials and methods
Rescue of recombinant viruses
CV1 cells were transfected with the plasmid containing the FPV-HA gene under RNA Pol I control along with expression plasmids encoding the proteins (PB1, PB2, PA, NP) of the influenza virus polymerase complex. 36 hours post transfection cells were infected either with the reassortant HK-WSN (H3N1) or WSN-HK (H1N2) and progeny viruses were harvested 16 hours p.i.. Selection for recombinant viruses was performed using a neutralizing anti H3 serum (HK-WSN system) or by passaging of supernatants on MDBK cells in the absence of trypsin (WSN-HK system). Recombinamnt viruses were purified by three plaque passages on MDBK cells.
Analysis of virus growth
For growth curves MDBK or MDCK cells were infected at a multiplicity of infection (M.O.I.) of 0.0005 and HA titers in the supernatant monitored at various times p.i.. Plaque assays were done on MDCK and MDBK cells according to common methods.
Release of virus by VCNA treatment
Cells were infected at an M.O.I. > 1 for 10 hours. Vibrio cholerae neuraminidase (VCNA) was added to a concentration of 25 mU/ml for 2 hours. Infected cells not treated with VCNA were used as a control. Virus titers in supernatants were determined by plaque assay (infection of cells were done on ice to prevent an inhibitory effect of VCNA on virus binding).
Results
Analysis of recombinant viruses
RNA was isolated from viruses and subjected to RT-PCR with FPV-HA specific primers. RT-PCR fragments were checked by endonuclease digestion for the presense of a restriction site which had been introduced into the plasmid based HA-gene.
HA from metabolically labelled viruses was immunoprecipitated and analysed in an SDS-PAGE. These approaches confirmed the recombinant nature and the presence of the desired mutations in the HA of the rescued viruses.
Spread in cell culture
Cells infected at low multiplicity with recombinant viruses were monitored at various times p.i. for the HA-titer in the medium. With viruses of the N1-series there was a marked decrease of virus growth. Release of the G1,2 mutant was retarded and virus yields in the medium were reduced about tenfold.
Likewise, there was a reduction in plaque size that was distinct with G1,2 and less pronounced with G2.
With viruses of the N2-series we detected a plaque size reduction for the G12 virus while G1 and G2 viruses were unaffected.
Release of virus from infected cells
Growth restrictions of the glycosylation mutated viruses as described above could be attributed to an impaired release from infected cells by means of treatment with Vibrio cholerae neuraminidase (VCNA) (Fig. 1). With G2 and G12 viruses of the N1-series VCNA treatment was an absolut requirement for the quantitativ release of progeny viruses from the cells. Without VCNA treatment G2-viruses were released to only 19% and G1,2 viruses to only 6%. In the group of N2-NA containing viruses only the release of the G1,2 mutant was dependent on VCNA treatment.
Click here to see Fig. 1: Release of glycosylation-mutant viruses from infected cells.
Columns indicate the extend of release of individual viruses in the absence of VCNA. Titers are given as percent values of the amount of virus released after VCNA treatment (which were set to 100 %).
Discussion
By sequential removal of oligosaccharide side chains from the tip of the HA molecule we have shown that receptor binding activity is gradually regulated by these glycans. Furthermore, this regulation of receptor binding is highly dependent on the nature of the accompanying viral NA. Since it has recently been described that HA-glycosylation and NA-subtype play a crucial role in determining host range and adaption to new hosts of influenza viruses (2) we have set the stage for specific manipulation of these functions aiming at the construction of influenza viruses with defined growth characteristics.
In conclusion, our reverse genetics approach provides an excellent experimental tool for studying the interaction and matching of different types of HA and NA species and for the generation of influenza viruses with precisely modulated receptor binding activity.
References
The influenza A virus M1 protein interacts with the human RACK1 (receptor of activated C kinase) protein
Jens Reinhardt and Thorsten Wolff
Institut für Virologie, Philipps-Universität, Marburg, Germany
Introduction
Influenza viruses utilize and manipulate host cell functions. We are interested to identify cellular factors that are targeted by the virus through protein-protein interactions. We have previously identified host proteins that interact with the viral NS1 protein (1) and have extended these studies to the M1 matrix protein of the influenza A virus. The M1 protein has been reported to have both structural and regulatory roles in virion assembly and disassembly, viral RNA transcription and intracellular transport of the genomic RNP segments. In addition, M1 proteins of influenza virus subtypes A, B and C were found to be phosphorylated on serine and threonine residues in infected cells. The significance of M1 protein phosphorylation and the corresponding kinases have not been determined yet. We hypothesized that one or more of the properties of the M1 protein are mediated by interactions with unknown cellular factors. In order to identify such cellular components, we have used the yeast two-hybrid system with the M1 protein as a bait. As a result, we isolated four independent cDNA clones that interacted specifically with the M1 protein in the yeast two hybrid system and corresponded to the highly conserved RACK1 (receptor of activated C kinase) protein. RACK1 has been previously suggested to serve as an intracellular receptor protein for activated protein kinase C (PKC) (2). We discuss a possible role of the M1-RACK1 interaction for phosphorylation of the M1 protein.
Materials and methods
Yeast two hybrid screening
M1 cDNA of the influenza A/PR/8/34 virus was subcloned into pEG202 as a translational fusion with the DNA binding domain of the bacterial LexA protein. We used the yeast two hybrid system (3) to screen 1.2 x 106 independent HeLa cell cDNA clones for interaction with the LexA-M1 fusion protein as measured by their ability to activate a LEU2 and a lacZ reporter gene simultanously. A total of four cDNAs were isolated that corresponded to the human RACK1 protein and interacted specifically with LexA-M1 but not with an unrelated LexA fusion construct.
GST-coprecipitation analysis
RACK1 cDNA was expressed in E. coli as a glutathione-S-transferase (GST) fusion protein. GST-RACK1 was purified and immobilized on glutathione agarose beads and used to select proteins from extracts of metabolically labelled MDCK cells infected with the mouse-adapted influenza A/WSN/33 virus. Precipitated proteins were analyzed by SDS gel electrophoresis.
In vitro phosphorylation of recombinant M1 protein
GST and GST-M1 fusion proteins were expressed in E. coli and purified from bacterial lysates by adsorption to glutathione agarose. Immobilized GST proteins were incubated with purified protein kinase C (Calbiochem) and 10 mCi of g-32P-ATP for 15 minutes at 30° C. The GST proteins were subsequently washed and analyzed by SDS gel electrophoresis.
Results and Discussion
We used the M1 protein as a bait in the yeast two hybrid system to screen a human cDNA expression library for interacting factors. 4 cDNAs corresponding to the human RACK1 (receptor of activated C kinase) protein that interacted specifically with the M1 protein were isolated. The genetic interaction was confirmed by the specific coprecipitation of the M1 protein from extracts of virus-infected cells by using a GST-RACK1 fusion protein in a a GST-pull down assay (Fig.1).
Click here to see Fig. 1: Specific coprecipitation of the M1 protein from influenza A/WSN/33 virus-infected cells by GST-RACK1. GST-RACK1 fusion protein and GST were expressed in E. coli and immobilized on glutathione agarose. The coated beads were used to select proteins from extracts of 35S-labelled MDCK cells that were infected with influenza A/WSN/33 virus or mock-infected. The precipitated proteins were analyzed by SDS gel electrophoresis. Positions of the viral NP, M1 and NS1 proteins are indicated to the left.
RACK1 is a highly conserved 36 kDa protein that contains seven WD40 domains. WD40 domains are contained in a variety of regulatory proteins and mediate protein-protein interactions. RACK1 has been suggested to function as an intracellular receptor protein that anchors the activated form of PKC at membranes or components of the cytoskeleton in close proximity to its substrates (2). With respect to the M1-RACK1 interaction we wondered if PKC would mediate phosphorylation of the M1 protein. We could demonstrate that recombinant M1 protein is phosphorylated by purified PKC in vitro. We are currently analyzing if M1 phosphorylation by PKC also occurs during viral infection. These findings may indicate that the M1-RACK1 interaction functions during phosphorylation of the M1 protein.
References:
(1) Wolff, T., ONeill, R. E. and P. Palese (1998). NS1-binding protein (NS1-BP): A novel human protein that interacts with the influenza A virus nonstructural NS1 protein is relocalized in the nuclei of infected cells. J. Virol. 72, 7170-7180.
(2) Ron, D., Chen, C.-H., Caldwell, J., Jamieson, L., Orr, E. and D. Mochly-Rosen (1994). Cloning of an intracellular receptor for protein kinase C: A homolog of the b subunit of G proteins. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 91, 839-843.
(3) Zervos, A.S., Gyuris, J. and R. Brent (1993). Mxi1, a protein that specifically interacts with Max to bind Myc-Max recognition sites. Cell 72, 223-232.
The mammalian influenza virus A/WSN/33 (H1N1) causes a systemic infection in chicken embryos.
Anke Feldmann, Ralf Wagner, Astrid Herwig, Thorsten Wolff and Hans-Dieter Klenk
Insitut für Virologie, Philipps-Universität, Marburg, Germany
Introduction
Cleavage of hemagglutinin into its subunits HA1 and HA2 is a prerequisite for influenza virus infectivity. Cleavage is accomplished by a variety of cellular proteases depending on the amino acid composition of the connecting peptide between HA1 and HA2. Hemagglutinins of highly pathogenic avian influenza viruses possess multibasic cleavage sites that are recognized by ubiquitously expressed proteases like furin or PC5/PC6. These viruses replicate in cell culture without addition of exogenous proteases to the medium. In chickens these strains cause systemic infections. In contrast, apathogenic avian influenza viruses and most human strains possess a single arginine residue at the cleavage site. HA of these strains is cleaved by secreted proteases of epithelial cells, e.g. tryptase Clara or Factor X. In infected animals the infection of these viruses is usually limited to the upper respiratory or intestinal tract. The addition of trypsin to the medium is therefore necessary for productive replication of these viruses in cell culture.
An exception is the influenza virus A/WSN/33 (H1N1) that possesses only a single arginine residue at the cleavage site but replicates in some cell lines without addition of exogenous proteases. In mice, infection is not only limited to the lungs but virus can be found in various tissues of infected animals. Recently it was shown that WSN-NA promotes cleavage of WSN-HA by sequestering of plasminogen.
We were interested to analyze whether WSN like pathogenic avian influenza viruses causes a systemic infection in chicken embryos and if the "gene constellation" of WSN has an influence on the spread of infection.
Material and methods
Influenza virus strains used: A/FPV/Rostock/34 (H7N1); A/chick/Germany/N/34 (H10N7); A/WSN/33 (H1N1); A/HK-WSN (H3N1); A/WSN-HK (H1N2); A/H7WSN-HK (H7N2); A/H7HK-WSN (H7N1).
11 day old chicken embryos were infected via the allantoic route with the virus strains listed above. 18h (FPV) or 48h (others) after infection the bodies of the embryos were frozen in isopentane cooled on dry ice. 20µm cryosections were prepared and viral RNA was detected by in situ hybridization technique using 35S-UTP labeled riboprobes specific for mRNA of H7 (FPV), H1 (WSN), H10 (Virus N) NP(Aichi) and NA (WSN). Bound radioactivity was visualized by exposition of the labeled slices to X-ray screen. Cell tropism studies were performed by covering the slides by liquid nuclear emulsion followed by a two days exposure. Sections were then developed and counterstained by hematoxilin-eosin.
Results
In earlier experiments we compared the organ and cell tropism of the highly pathogenic FPV and the apathogenic Virus N. When 11 day-old chicken embryos were infected with FPV all organs were heavily labeled by the H7-specific riboprobe reflecting the systemic infection caused by this virus. In contrast, in chicken embryos infected with Virus N only the cloaca which is connected with the allantoic cavity was stained by the H10-specific riboprobe (Fig.1).
The ubiquitous expression of the activating proteases of FPV HA such as furin explains the extensive spread of FPV into all organs of the chicken embryo. Consequently replication of Virus N whose HA is activated by secreted proteases present in the allantoic fluid is limited to the allantoic cavity and adjacent organs.
We found out that the mammalian strain WSN also causes a systemic infection in chicken embryos indistinguishable from that of FPV. In contrast, infection of the reassortant strain A/WSN-HK (H1N2) that differs from WSN only by carrying a different neuraminidase is limited to the allantoic fluid and the cloaca like that of the apathogenic avian Virus N. We substiuted the HA of A/WSN-HK (H1N2) by FPV HA using techniques of reverse genectics and generated a recombinant influenza virus A/H7WSN-HK (H7N2). We can show that this recombinant influenza virus like WSN and FPV replicates in all organs of the chicken embryo.
Discussion
Our results demonstrate that there is no difference concerning organ tropism of WSN and FPV infection in chicken embryos. The systemic infection of FPV is explained by the ubiquitous expression of its activating protease. Concerning WSN the set of virus strains we used suggests that the WSN-NA has influence on the extend of the infection. Thus the model of activation of WSN-HA promoted by the sequestering of plasminogen by WSN-NA may also count in chickens.
At last we want to emphasize that the present study proposes the embryonated egg as a convenient system to test pathogenic properties not only of avian influenza strains.
References:
Genetics of the variation in sensitivity to zanamivir of in vitro replication of naturally occurring avian influenza viruses
S.J. Baigent1, R.C. Bethell2 and J.W. McCauley1
1Institute for Animal Health, Compton, Newbury, UK; 2Glaxo Wellcome, Stevenage, UK
Introduction
The sialic acid analogue 4-guanidino-2,4-dideoxy-2,3-dehydro-N-acetylneuraminic acid (zanamivir) is a high affinity, high specificity inhibitor of all naturally-occurring influenza A and B virus NAs (1). Zanamivir-resistant variants, having mutations in either the HA or the NA, have been selected following repeated passage in the presence of the drug in tissue culture (see 2). We previously demonstrated that naturally-occurring avian influenza viruses show variation in sensitivity of their replication to zanamivir in tissue culture (3). A/Duck/Ireland/113/83 H5N8 (Duck Ireland) is highly sensitive, A/FPV/Egypt/45 H7N1 (Egypt) and A/FPV/England/1/63 H7N3 (Langham) show intermediate sensitivity and SD17 (H7N1, a reassortant having HA and NA from A/FPV/Rostock/34) is relatively resistant. However, for each of the four viruses, the NA activity is inhibited by zanamivir, while the haemagglutinating activity is relatively insensitive to zanamivir. Reassortant viruses, produced between pairs of these four parent avian viruses, were studied in order to identify the genes which contribute to the variation in sensitivity to zanamivir in vitro and to define the mechanism by which these genes influence sensitivity. This knowledge could be used to predict the properties of new human pandemic influenza viruses that may emerge on widespread use of zanamivir.
Materials and methods
Reassortant viruses, produced by co-infection of chick embryo fibroblast cells, were genotyped using serological analysis, nucleic acid analysis, and electrophoretic analysis of virus polypeptides. For each parent virus, and for 54 reassortants, the effect of zanamivir on virus replication in MDCK cells was examined in multi-cycle plaque formation assays and in single-cycle virus yield assays. Virus yield was measured by either infectivity titre or by haemagglutination titre. Mean IC50 values (the concentration of zanamivir required to decrease virus replication by 50%) were determined, and the effect of genotype on sensitivity to zanamivir analysed using the Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test (4). Ability of the viruses to elute from chick erythrocytes at 370C was studied. The length of the stalk region of each NA was determined by sequencing of PCR products. The locations of potential glycosylation sites on the four HA trimers were determined from the amino acid sequences of these molecules.
Results
Analysis of the reassortant viruses showed that both sensitivity of virus to zanamivir in tissue culture, and ability of virus to elute from erythrocytes, are determined by segment 4 (HA) and segment 6 (NA) and are independent of the remaining six RNA segments.
In each of the three tissue culture assays, SD17 HA was associated with lowest sensitivity to zanamivir in tissue culture and with ability to elute from erythrocytes (table 1). SD17 HA, unlike the other three HAs, possesses a glycan at position 158 (H3 numbering), close to the receptor binding site. For a given HA type, SD17 NA and Langham NA were associated with lowest sensitivity to zanamivir in tissue culture and with inability to elute from erythrocytes (table 1). These two NAs have short stalks (34 and 28 amino acids respectively). Egypt NA and Duck Ireland NA conferred greatest sensitivity in tissue culture and were associated with ability to elute from chick erythrocytes (table 1). These two NAs have long stalks (56 and 52 amino acids respectively).
Table 1
|
HA |
NA |
n |
Mean IC50 nM (plaque assay) |
Elution from erythrocytes |
|
S |
S |
12 |
182 |
+ |
|
L |
3 |
238 |
+ |
|
|
E |
3 |
23 |
+ |
|
|
D |
3 |
5 |
+ |
|
|
L |
S |
3 |
34 |
- |
|
L |
9 |
46 |
- |
|
|
E |
2 |
3 |
+ |
|
|
D |
1 |
4 |
+ |
|
|
E |
S |
3 |
3 |
- |
|
L |
2 |
1 |
- |
|
|
E |
7 |
3 |
+ |
|
|
D |
0 |
- |
No virus |
|
|
D |
S |
2 |
46 |
- |
|
L |
2 |
2 |
- |
|
|
E |
1 |
3 |
+ |
|
|
D |
2 |
2 |
+ |
S=SD17; L=Langham; E=Egypt; D=Duck Ireland
+ virus able to elute; - virus unable to elute
Discussion
The differential sensitivities of avian influenza viruses to zanamivir in tissue culture can be explained by the properties of their HA and NA. We suggest that sialic acid bound to position 158 of SD17 HA may fill the receptor binding pocket, competing with sialic acid attached to cellular receptors or to virus particles. Thus, viruses having this HA can elute from receptors with decreased dependence on NA activity and are less sensitive to zanamivir in tissue culture.
A long-stalked NA is more efficient in releasing virus from receptors than is a short-stalked (inefficient) NA, so viruses having long-stalked NAs can elute efficiently from receptors in the absence of zanamivir. However, because a long-stalked NA plays a greater role in release of virus from cells than does a short-stalked NA, viruses having a long-stalked NA are more sensitive to zanamivir in tissue culture.
References
Cytokines in the pathogenesis of influenza
K. Van Reeth
Laboratory of Virology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Gent, Belgium
Uncomplicated influenza in man and animals is characterized by an abrupt onset of fever, chills, loss of apetite, myalgias, and respiratory signs. The target cell for the virus is the epithelial cell along the entire respiratory tract, but the pattern of infection and the relative involvement of the lower respiratory tract seem to vary in different animal species. Histological studies of the upper respiratory tract and/or lungs typically reveal necrosis of epithelial cells and infiltration with neutrophils. Despite extensive clinical and pathologic descriptions, the causes of disease symptoms and pathology remain largely unexplored. There is, however, growing evidence that so-called early cytokines produced at the site of infection mediate both symptom formation and inflammation. Among these cytokines are interferon-alpha (IFN-a), tumour necrosis factor-a (TNF-a), interleukin-1 and interleukin-6, and several chemokines. This review concentrates on several aspects of the cytokine response during acute influenza: 1) Cytokine profiles in the respiratory tract; 2) Cytokine induction at the cellular level; 3) The role of specific cytokines in influenza pathogenesis. Special emphasis is paid to studies in man and natural influenza virus hosts.
Cytokine profiles during influenza in man and swine
The kinetics of several cytokines have been studied during experimental influenza virus infections of humans and swine. In human volunteers, systemic disease and upper respiratory illness were most prominent (2). IFN-a, IL-6, TNF-a and IL-8 were found in nasal secretions during the period of maximal symptoms. IFN-a and IL-6 correlated directly with viral titers and illness severity. Other cytokines such as IL-1b, IL-2 or TGF-b did not show significant increases.
Using gnotobiotic pigs, an experimental model to reproduce "swine flu" has been developed in the authors laboratory (7). The typical clinicopathological manifestations include fever, anorexia, depression, severe dyspnoea and a necrotizing bronchopneumonia. High levels of IFN-a, TNF-a and IL-1 were detected in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluids within 1 day after infection. When cytokine concentrations, lung virus titers and BAL neutrophil counts were compared, a direct correlation between the three was noted. In addition, the rise and fall of cytokine production exactly coincided with clinical symptoms.
Cytokine induction at the cellular level
The mechanisms of cytokine induction by the influenza virus are still unclear. There is no answer yet to several pertinent questions such as: Does cytokine production occur in infected or bystander cells? Which viral genes/proteins are involved? Do mechanisms of induction differ for different cytokines? Some in vitro IFN-a and TNF-a studies have revealed conflicting data. Cytokine production is strongly cell-type-dependent, and the use of different cell types may account for discrepancies in in vitro studies (1). So far, the in vivo cytokine producing cells during influenza have not been characterized. Therefore, we set out to determine the cellular origin of IFN-a and TNF-a in the lung of influenza virus-infected pigs. Preliminary results will be presented at the symposium.
Further proof for a role of cytokines during influenza
Cytokines are part of a complex network, and the role of individual cytokines in vivo is difficult to determine. Here again, experimental studies using different approaches and animal species have given conflicting results. The effects of specific anti-cytokine strategies have been examined in murine models only (3, 4, 5). These studies have confirmed the significance of TNF-a, IL-1b, IL-1a and IFN-a in influenza pathogenesis. However, the effect of blocking individual cytokines was only partial and in some cases very modest. Studies in ferrets, on the other hand, failed to find evidence for a role of IL-1, IL-6 and TNF-a in influenza-induced fever (6).
References
1. Bussfeld, D., Bacher, M., Moritz, A., Gemsa, D. and Sprenger, H. (1997) Expression of transcription factor genes after influenza A virus infection. Immunobiology, 198(1-3): 291-298.
2. Hayden, F.G., Fritz, R., Lobo, M.C., Alvord, W., Strober, W. and Straus, S.E. (1998) Local and systemic cytokine responses during experimental human influenza A virus infection. Relation to symptom formation and host defense. J. Clin. Invest., 101(3): 643-649.
3. Kozak, W., Zheng, H., Conn, C.A., Soszynski, D., Van der Ploeg, L.H.T. and Kluger, M.J. (1995) Thermal and behavioral effects of lipopolysaccharide and influenza in interleukin-1b-deficient mice. Am. J. Physiol., 269: R969-977.
4. Kurokawa, M., Imakita, M., Kumeda and C.A., Shiraki, K. (1996) Cascade of fever production in mice infected with influenza virus. J. Med. Virol., 50: 152-158.
5. Peper, R.L. and Van Campen, H. (1995) Tumor necrosis factor as a mediator of inflammation in influenza A viral pneumonia. Microbial Pathogenesis, 19: 175-183.
6. Price, G.E., Fenton, R.J., Smith, H. and Sweet, C. (1997) Are known pyrogenic cytokines responsible for fever in influenza? J. Med. Virol., 52(3): 336-340.
7. Van Reeth, K., Nauwynck, H. and Pensaert, M. (1998) Bronchoalveolar interferon-alpha, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, interleukin-1, and inflammation during acute influenza in pigs: a possible model for humans? J. Infect. Dis., 177(4): 1076-1079.
Examining the role of transforming growth factor-b and apoptosis in the pathogenesis of Hong Kong/156 in chickens
S. Schultz-Cherry and D. Swayne
Southeast Poultry Research Laboratory, United States Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Research Service, 934 College Station Road, Athens, Georgia 30605, USA
Introduction
Virulent strains of influenza A virus continue to cause severe losses to the poultry industry worldwide. Highly pathogenic strains of avian influenza (AI) virus causes systemic infection and rapid death in chickens. Prior to 1997 avian influenza viruses were not considered a direct threat to human health. The outbreak in Hong Kong and the death of 6 people changed the thinking. Many elegant comparative studies showed that the avian and human Hong Kong strains of virus are identical, suggesting the cross-species transmission is not directly related to changes in the viral genes.
Although a great deal is known about influenza viruses, very little is known about viral pathogenesis. Influenza viruses induce apoptosis, or programmed cell death in cells in vitro and in vivo. The role of apoptosis in pathogenesis is unclear.
Studies using the highly pathogenic strain A/Turkey/Ontario/7732/66 (Ty/Ont) suggested the lymphocyte depletion observed in infected chickens is a direct result of apoptosis. Additional work showed that transforming growth factor-b (TGF-b), a highly conserved growth regulatory protein, is directly activated by influenza virus and induces apoptosis. Increased TGF-b activity was found within 8 hrs after chickens were infected with Ty/Ont. Interestingly, chickens infected with an equivalent concentration of A/Mallard/Wisconsin, a low pathogenic strain, showed no increased TGF-b activity and very little apoptosis.
In these studies, chickens infected with A/Hong Kong/156/1997 were examined for histopathology, increased TGF-b activity, and levels of apoptosis.
Material and Methods
Histopathology
A/Hong Kong/156/97 (H5N1) (106 mean embryo lethal doses) was intranasally inoculated into 4-week-old chickens. Birds were euthanatized at 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 24, 36 and 48 hours post-inoculation (PI) with sodium pentobarbital. Select tissues were fixed in neutral buffered formalin solution and routinely processed to paraffin blocks and histologic sections.
The lungs of infected and control chickens were aseptically collected and stored in saline at 70C. After homogenization, the tissue extracts were filtered through a 0.22 mm syringe and tested in the normal rat kidney colony forming soft agar assay for TGF-b activity.
Detection of apoptosis
Serial sections of the described tissues were specifically stained for apoptotic cell death using a TUNEL assay (Boehringer Manheim).
Results
No lesions or viral antigen were identified at 1, 2, 4, 8 and 16 hours PI. At 24 hours, AI viral antigen was present in the nasal cavity within respiratory epithelium and inflammatory cells. Histologically, mild heterohistiocytic rhinitis was present, especially in the infraorbital sinus and ventrum of the middle nasal septum adjacent to the choanal slit. Degeneration and cell death was present in respiratory epithelium. The spleen and cecal tonsils had AI viral antigen in macrophages and capillary endothelial cells. At 36 and 48 hours, degeneration and cell death were widespread in multiple visceral organs and the brain. Viral antigen was present in many cell types, especially in vascular endothelial cells, various epithelial cells and macrophages.
Increased apoptotic cell death was observed in the lungs and nasal septum 8 hours pi. Within 24 hours, there was a systemic increase in apoptosis, even in areas that failed to stain with viral antigen. Active TGF-b levels in the lungs of HK 156 infected chickens increased slightly 8 hours pi, but surprisingly dropped to background by 24 hours and remained level at 48 hours. These results are similar to chickens infected with the low path strain A/Mallard/Wisconsin. In contrast, chickens infected with Ty/Ont showed dramatic increases in TGF-b activity throughout the 72 hour experiment. The reason for these differences is unknown.
Discussion
In these studies we show that Hong Kong 156 virus initially replicates in the respiratory epithelium, followed by rapid dissemination throughout the body. Increased apoptosis is seen early after infection and increases with time. In contrast to another highly pathogenic strain of avian influenza virus, HK 156 fails to activate TGF-b. The reason for this is unclear.
Humoral and cellular immune responses of pigs to an infection with influenza virus or after vaccination.
P.P. Heinen, A.P. van Nieuwstadt, E.A de Boer-Luijtze and A.T.J. Bianchi
Department of Mammalian Virology, Institute for Animal Science and Health (ID-DLO), Lelystad, The Netherlands
Introduction.
Vaccination of pigs against influenza is currently performed by two times intra-muscular application of an inactivated " whole-virus" vaccine, containing adjuvant. Such a vaccine induces high IgG antibody titres in the blood and can protect against clinical signs of disease, but protection against an infection and antigenically different virus strains of the same subtype remains questionable. We believe that a vaccination procedure that stimulates more of a mucosal immune response and cellular immunity will provide better protection. Therefore, we started a study to compare immune responses after natural infection or vaccination. An influenza challenge model in specified pathogen free (SPF) pigs was developed, and tools to analyse the immune response.
Materials and methods.
In a first experiment, six ten-week-old pigs were inoculated into the nostrils with an aerosol of the field isolate A/Swine/Neth/St. Oedenrode/96 (H3N2). ELISAs were developed to measure influenza virus nucleoprotein specific IgM, IgG1 and IgA antibodies. These isotype-specific ELISAs were used to monitor antibody responses in serum and at the mucosa of the respiratory tract after a primary infection with influenza virus. Also, the total Ig isotype concentrations were quantified, using an ELISA and the specific activity (titre of antibody / concentration of immunoglobulin) for each isotype in BALF and NLF was compared with that in serum collected at the same time.
In a second experiment humoral and cellular immune responses after vaccination and infection were compared. A lymphocyte proliferation test (LPT) was developed and attempts were made to develop a cytotoxic lymphocyte test (CTL) to analyse the cellular immune response. FACS analysis was used to phenotype the T cell subsets that were involved in the influenza-induced cellular immune response. Protection after infection or vaccination was measured by monitoring signs of disease, virus excretion and infection of contact animals.
Results.
Experiment 1:
The aerosol infection with influenza virus caused acute respiratory disease characterised by fever, dyspnoea and anorexia. An exudative endobronchitis was observed throughout the lung and viral antigens were present in the epithelial cells of the bronchi and bronchioli on post-infection days 1 and 2. Virus was isolated from bronchioalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), nasal lavage fluid (NLF) and from pharyngeal swabs until 5 days after infection.
Kinetics of IgM, IgG and IgA responses were determined in the blood and at the respiratory mucosa, with the isotype-specific ELISAs. The influenza specific activity of IgA in NLF was 570 and in BALF it was 280 times higher than in blood. The influenza specific activity of IgG1 was 8 times higher in BALF than in blood.
Experiment 2:
Humoral and cellular immune responses after infection or vaccination with influenza virus were studied.
Discussion.
The results indicate an active secretion of locally produced IgA antibodies into the nose and lungs and transudation of locally produced IgG1 into the lung after infection with influenza virus. These mucosal antibodies can provide local protection against re-infection. Conventional vaccination with an inactivated whole-virus vaccine with an adjuvant provokes mainly a systemic IgG response, which will protect against pneumonia. The development of immunisation procedures that stimulate mucosal IgA production may improve efficacy of vaccination.
IgM antibodies specific for influenza virus were detectable for a short period after infection. Therefore, the IgM ELISA can be used for the diagnosis of a recent infection with influenza virus.
The challenge model in SPF pigs and our studies of humoral and cellular immune responses will improve our insight into immunity of pigs against influenza and will provide a rational basis for improvement of the vaccine.
Respiratory tract and systemic humoral and cellular immune responses to influenza virus infection in pigs
D.L. Larsen1*, N. Dybahal-Sissoko1, A. Karasin1, S. Carey1, F. Zuckermann2, and C.W. Olsen1
1Department of Pathobiological Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI 53706; 2Department of Veterinary Pathobiology, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61802
Introduction
Influenza virus is a common respiratory pathogen of pigs (1). Pigs that have recovered from infection are protected from further challenge, but the currently available inactivated-virus vaccine doesnt consistently induce complete protection (2). We have investigated DNA vaccination in pigs using the hemagglutinin (HA) gene of a prototypical swine virus. However, to assess the responses to vaccination, we need to understand the protective immune responses to natural infection, both systemically and at mucosal surfaces in the respiratory tract. To accomplish this we infected pigs with A/Swine/Indiana/1726/88 (Sw/IN) (H1N1) (3). At various times after infection we monitored antibody production and we enumerated antibody secreting cells (ASC) and IFN-g secreting cells by ELISPOT (4).
Materials and methods
Fifteen 8-week old influenza seronegative pigs were infected intranasally on day 0 with 2x105 EID50 Sw/IN (H1N1). Three pigs were rechallenged with the same dose on day 42. Nasal swabs were taken for virus isolation on days 3-7 after primary infection and on days 3 and 6 after rechallenge. Three infected and one uninfected control pig were euthanized and sampled on days 7, 14, 21 and 42 post primary infection and 14 days after rechallenge. The following table outlines the samples taken and assays performed.
|
ELISA & HI |
ASC ELISPOT |
IFN-g ELISPOT |
|
serum |
whole blood |
whole blood |
|
nasal wash |
lymph nodes of the head |
lymph nodes of the head |
|
bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) |
tracheobronchial lymph node |
tracheobronchial lymph node |
|
spleen |
spleen |
|
|
cells from nasal mucosa |
cells from nasal mucosa |
|
|
cells from pharyngeal mucosa |
cells from pharyngeal mucosa |
|
|
cells from BAL |
Results
All 15 pigs shed virus for 6 or 7 days and showed mild clinical signs after primary infection, but the 3 pigs that were rechallenged on day 42 were completely protected and did not shed virus. Virus-specific serum IgG, IgA, and HI titers all peaked 2-3 weeks after primary infection and did not substantially increase after rechallenge. The predominant virus-specific isotype in serum was IgG. Pigs responded with virus-specific IgG and IgA in both the upper (nasal washes) and lower (BAL) airways. However, IgA was the predominant isotype in both sites. Results of the ASC ELISPOT assays demonstrated that the highest numbers of both IgG and IgA secreting cells are present in the nasal mucosa. In contrast, IFN-g secreting cells were predominately localized to the spleen and tracheobronchial lymph nodes.
Discussion
These results give a detailed description of the kinetics and phenotype of the immune response to influenza virus infection in the pig. This information will be useful in the evaluation the immune responses to future influenza DNA vaccine studies in swine and help in determining which responses are important in protection from infection.
This research was supported by a USDA NRICGP grant.
References
Quantification of the association between mean geometric titre (MGT) against two subtypes of influenza viruses and prevalence of pleurisy in batches of slaughterpigs.
Oliveira, J; Guitián, F.J.; Sanjuán, M.L.; Yus, E.
Infectious Diseases and Epidemiology, Veterinary College of Lugo, University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain
Introduction
Swine influenza (SI) is a highly contagious, viral disease characterised by coughing, dyspnea, fever and prostration. In pig farms, morbidity is usually high (up to 100%) while mortality normally does not exceed 5 or 10% due mainly to secondary bacterial infections. Until now, in European countries, influenza viruses (IV) from pigs of the H1N1 and H3N2 subtypes have mainly been isolated. This infection contributes facilitating the setting-up of secondary bacterial infections, which cause important lesions in the respiratory system. Lung and pleura lesions, due to their chronic character, can be seen at the moment of the inspection at the slaughterhouse. Several studies have showed the relationships between lung and pleura lesions, recorded at slaughter, and poor productive performance, especially in fattening pigs(3). But lung and pleura lesions are influenced and associated to multiple factors both at individual as group level (another infections, environment, management, season, age of animals etc.). Some of these factors could be also associated to influenza infections and such factors could confound the true association between infection of influenza virus and respiratory system lesions recorded at slaughter(1). For example large pigs farms have a higher risk of virus infection than small farms, but often large farms have better management and environmental conditions than small farms, so if farm size is not taken into account a association high seroprevalence against some infections agents and low prevalence of lesions could be found and it would be concluded that infections be a protector factor of lesions.
Interaction virus influenza-secondary bacteria infection has been mainly reported at individual level but little research has been carried out at batch or farm level(2). The goal of this study is assessing and quantifying the association between geometric mean titre (MGT) against to two subtypes of IV and prevalence of pleurisy (PP) in batches of slaughterpigs adjusting for potential confounding factors.
Material and methods
During a month six period blood samples from slaughterpigs were collected and the lungs of such pigs were inspected for the presence of lung and pleura lesions. A total of 22 pig batches from fattening farms with a system all in-all out integrated in a regional Co-operative were inspected a blood sampled in a slaughterhouse in NW Spain. None of batches had been vaccinated against any subtype of IV. The number of pigs studied in each batch ranged from 10 to 50 (due to practical constraints non systematic randomization could be attempted and could not match serum samples and lesion on individual level).
Serum samples were tested using the IHA method (previously described by Palmer) against the subtypes H1N1 (strain A/NJ/8/76) and H3N2 (strain A/Victoria/1/75). Mean geometric titre (MGT) in each batch was calculated as:
MGT= Click here to see Formula 1.
Two types of pneumonic lesions in each pig inspected were recorded: the percentage of lung surface with dark brown consolidation (typical lesion caused by Mycoplasma Hyopneumoniae) and the presence or absence of fibrinous or fibrous tissue in external or internal pleura(pleurisy). Prevalence of pleurisy (PP) in the batch was calculated as the number of pigs with pleurisy divided by total number of pigs inspected. Severity of pneumonia (SP) into batch was calculated as:
SP= Click here to see Formula 2.
The total size of the batch, bimonth period when the batch was inspected and days in fattening farm were also recorded. A regression univariant analysis was carried out to calculate the crude association (B coefficients) between GMT against A/NJ/8/76 (MGTH1)1 and GMT against A/Victoria/1/75 (MGTH3) and PP (dependent variable). In the same way other factors were analysed.
In order to test and quantify the adjusted association between GMTH1 and GMTH3 and PP a multivarate regression model was elaborated. The variables: bimonth period, batch size and days of fattening were forced in the model because they were considered potential confounding factors. The other variables were allowed to enter models using a stepwise-selection procedure (P -to- enter=0,15 and P -to- remove=0,20)
Results.
In table 1 the crude association (B coefficients) of univariate models were showed. All variables analysed were significant at a significance level of 0,10. Table 2 shows the results of the multivariate model for quantifying the adjusted relationships between MGT against two subtypes of IV and dependent variable (PP). The SP (severity of pneumonic lesion) and the GMTH3 entered into the model together with the forced variables.
Table 1: Results of univariate analyses. Crude association (B coefficients) between some factors and PP obtained by univariate regression
|
B coefficients |
|
|
Number of animals tested in the batch |
0,43267995 |
|
Batch size |
0,01464993 |
|
S.P. |
0,88721515 |
|
Bimonth period |
|
|
May-June |
14,7901404 |
|
July-August |
6,28125 |
|
Sept.-October |
0 |
|
GMT |
|
|
GMTH1 |
2,13925412 |
|
GMTH3 |
37,7168785 |
|
Days of fattening |
0,84117777 |
Table 2: Results of final multivariable model for PP. Adjusted associations (B coefficients)
|
Factors in the model |
B coefficients |
Statistical significance. |
|
Constant |
-9,432 |
0,819 |
|
Days of fattening |
0,108 |
0,776 |
|
May-June |
7,260 |
0,276 |
|
Jul-August |
2,725 |
0,550 |
|
Sept-Oct |
0 |
- |
|
GMTH3 |
22,254 |
0,111 |
|
Herd size |
0,00821 |
0,227 |
|
S.P. |
0,688 |
0,039 |
Discussion
Since the number of cases studied is very small (only 22 batches) the power (capacity to detect significative associations) is very little. So a p-value of 0,15 was considered biologically relevant. The decision of forcing some variables was based on previous studies which indicated that such factors were associated both with influenza infections and with PP and in biological plausibility of such associations. The control of these factors is capital to avoid confounding. In the univariate analysis MGTH3 is associated with PP, but the other factors also showed a crude association at a level of 0,10. The crude association MGTH3 and PP is unadjusted and could disappear when controlling potential confounding factors. This possibility is rejected since the association is still in the final multivariable model. Obviously there are a lot of factors in farms (environmental, management, nutrition) which affect PP, but such factors are not associated to the introduction of disease carriers, the main cause of influenza infection in all in all out farms, so such factors, in field conditions, are not confounding factors.
An important factor, not recorded in this study, which could be associated both with influenza infection and with PP is the antibiotic medication during the growing and fattening period, but since all batches sampled were integrated in a Co-operative the antibiotic medication policy is very similar in this type of farms and in the period when the study was carried out no increasing antibiotic therapy was notified in any farm, so this factor, in this study, is not considered a confounding factor. The results of this study indicate that MGTH3 contributes to increase the prevalence of PP in batches of slaughterpigs. However, MGTH1 is not associated to an increase of PP yet MGTH1 at batch and individual level is higher than MGTH3. A possible pathogenic explanation would be that the infection by H3N2 influenza virus causes greater damage to the immune mechanisms of the respiratory system than H1N1 virus. But as the association found is at batch level it would be necessary to carry out an investigation at individual level to be sure. Another possibility to explain the no association GMTH1 and PP could be a poor elimination of non-specific inhibitors during the preparation of sera for IHA testing, so this would result in a bias of misclassification. Since PP has been associated with poor productive performances it would be of interest to carry out further investigations to assess the specific productive impact of influenza virus infection in fattening farms.
This study was financially supported by the Xunta de Galicia (XUGA 26105A95)
We are deeply grateful to the Coren co-operative for itscollaboration.
References
The continuing evolution of influenza viruses in pigs
I.H. Brown
Veterinary Laboratories Agency-Weybridge, New Haw, Addlestone, Surrey KT15 3NB, UK
Swine influenza (SI) was first observed at the time of the pandemic in humans in 1918 and it is known that the viruses responsible were closely related, possibly having derived from a common ancestor (1). Although the disease was described in pigs during the following years it was not until 1930 that the virus was isolated and identified. This H1N1 virus was the prototype strain of a group of viruses now known as classical viruses, which have been reported in pig populations worldwide.
Influenza A viruses of subtypes H1N1 and H3N2 have been widely reported in pigs, frequently associated with clinical disease. These include classical swine H1N1, avian-like H1N1 and human- and avian-like H3N2 viruses. Influenza is widespread and endemic in pig populations worldwide and is responsible for one of the most prevalent respiratory diseases in pigs.
SI generally appears with the introduction of new pigs into a herd, thereby being related to the movement of animals from infected to susceptible herds. Once a herd is infected the virus is likely to persist through the production of young susceptible pigs and the introduction of new stock. Infection is frequently subclinical, and typical symptoms are seen often in only 25 to 30 per cent of a herd. Swine husbandry practises influence directly the evolution of SI viruses through reduced immune pressure and constant availability of susceptible hosts, leading on the whole to reduced genetic drift in the genes encoding HA and NA, compared to those of similar viruses in the human population. However, mixing of pigs from multi-sources and the high frequency of contact with other species particularly humans provides an opportunity for cocirculation of viruses and genetic reassortment.
The classical H1N1 viruses have remained largely conserved both genetically and antigenically, although antigenic variants have been reported including strains in Canada since 1990 which have been associated with altered pathogenesis. In Europe, classical viruses have been largely replaced since 1979 by avian-like H1N1 viruses which are antigenically and genetically most closely related to H1N1 viruses isolated from ducks. Initially, following transmission to pigs, these viruses were genetically extremely unstable and it has been proposed that this was linked to a mutator mutation which may be necessary to enable influenza virus to cross the species barrier (2). Subsequently these viruses have become more stable establishing a new lineage in pigs. More recently an independent introduction of H1N1 virus from birds to pigs has occurred in Asia, and these viruses form a distinct sublineage of the Eurasian avian lineage.
Influenza A viruses of H3N2 subtype related closely to early human strains have been widely reported from pigs, particularly in Europe and Asia where they continue to circulate long after their disappearance from the human population. These viruses have evolved more slowly than their human counterparts and now form distinct lineages related to geographical location. In addition, some of the H3N2 viruses isolated from pigs in Asia are entirely avian-like, whilst other repeated introductions from humans appear to occur regularly. The maintenance of H3N2 viruses in pigs present a reservoir of virus which may in the future infect a susceptible human population.
The pig has been the leading contender for the role of intermediate host for reassortment of influenza A viruses. Pigs are the only mammalian species which are domesticated, reared in abundance and are susceptible to, and allow productive replication of avian and human influenza viruses. This susceptibility is due to the presence of both a 2,3- and a 2,6-galactose sialic acid linkages in cells lining the pig trachea which can result in modification of the receptor binding specificities of avian influenza viruses from a 2,3 to a 2,6 linkage thereby providing a potential link from birds to humans (3). The internal protein genes of human influenza viruses share a common ancestor with the genes of most swine influenza viruses. Also the pig has a broader host range concerning the compatibility of the nucleoprotein gene of viruses derived from other species. Experimental studies have shown that a wide diversity of avian influenza viruses (H1-H13) can be transmitted to pigs (4). Evidence for the pig as a mixing vessel of influenza viruses of non swine origin has been demonstrated in Europe with the detection of human-avian H3N2 reassortants (5) and human-avian H1N2 multiple reassortants (6) both of which have become established, regularly resulting in epidemics of disease in pigs. In addition, H1N2 viruses, derived from classical H1N1 and human-like H3N2 viruses have been isolated in France and Japan, where, in the latter case the virus spread and became associated with respiratory epizootics
Successful interspecies transmission of influenza viruses depends on the viral gene constellation with a progeny virus containing a specific constellation having the ability to replicate in the new host. In addition to these requirements it would appear that adaptation of a newly transmitted influenza virus to pigs can take many years. Both human H3N2 and avian H1N1 were detected in pigs many years before they acquired the ability to spread rapidly and become associated with disease epidemics in pigs.
Pigs serve as a major reservoirs of H1N1 and H3N2 influenza viruses and are frequently involved in interspecies transmission of influenza viruses. The maintenance of these viruses in pigs and the frequent introduction of viruses from other species may be important in the generation of new strains of influenza, some of which may have the potential to transmit to other species including humans.
References
Reid, A.H., Fanning, T.G., Hultin, J.V. & Taubenberger, J.K. (1998) Origin and evolution of the 1918 Spanish influenza virus hemagglutinin gene. Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci., 96:1651-1656
Scholtissek, C. (1996) Molecular evolution of influenza viruses. Virus Genes, 11:209-215
Ito, T, Couceiro, J.N., Kelm, S., Baum, L.G., Krauss, S., Castrucci, M.R., Donatelli, I., Kida, H., Paulson, J.C., Webster, R.G. & Kawaoka, Y. (1998) Molecular basis for the generation in pigs of influenza A viruses with pandemic potential. J. Virol., 72:7367-7373
Kida, H., Ito, T., Yasuda, J., Shimizu, Y., Itakura, C., Shortridge, K. F., Kawaoka, Y., & Webster, R. G. (1994). Potential for transmission of avian influenza viruses to pigs. J. Gen.Virol., 75: 2183-2188
Castrucci, M. R., Donatelli, I., Sidoli, L., Barigazzi, G., Kawaoka, Y. & Webster, R. G. (1993). Genetic reassortment between avian and human influenza A viruses in Italian pigs. Virology, 193: 503-506
Brown, I.H., Harris, P.A., McCauley, J.W. & Alexander, D.J. (1998) Multiple genetic reassortment of avian and human influenza A viruses in European pigs, resulting in the emergence of an H1N2 virus of novel genotype. J.Gen.Virol, 79: 2947-2955
Characterization of H3N2 influenza viruses from pigs in the United States
Nannan Zhou(1), Dennis A. Senne(2), John G. Landgraf(2), Sabrina L. Swenson(2), Scott Krauss(1), Robert G. Webster(1)*
* Presentor
Introduction
Influenza in pigs was first observed in the United States during the catastrophic 1918 human influenza pandemic. The H1N1 swine influenza virus has remained in the swine population and has been responsible for one of the most prevalent respiratory disease in pigs in North America. Serological studies of pigs in the United States in the late 1980s demonstrated that the classic H1 influenza virus continued to circulate at high frequency (51%) among pigs. The isolation of H3N2 influenza A virus from pigs was first recorded in Taiwan during a human epidemic in 1969. The subsequent isolation of a number of H3N2 strains of influenza virus and indirect evidence from serological surveillance indicated that H3N2 influenza virus variants have been introduced into the swine population in other parts of the world.(1) Previous studies indicate that there have been multiple introductions of H3N2 influenza virus into pigs in Asia and Europe. However, in the USA, H3N2 virus infection in pigs is rare, compared to the prevalence of H1N1 viruses.(2)
The present study examines the characteristics of four H3N2 swine influenza viruses isolated in the USA in 1998.
Material and Methods
Four swine viruses isolated from September to December of 1998 were used in this study. The four swine influenza viruses were derived from separate influenza outbreaks in four states including North Carolina (NC), Texas (TX), Minnesota (MN), and Iowa (IA). The viruses were isolated in chicken embryos from nasal swabs and tissues of sick and dead pigs. Antigenic, sequence analysis and phylogenetic analysis was done as previously described.(3)
Results
In August 1998, a flu-like outbreak occurred on a pig farm in North Carolina, USA. The outbreak was severe with high fever, respiratory signs and abortion in the breeding females with 10% mortality in the breeding females. In November and December 1998, influenza outbreaks occurred in pigs in Texas, Minnesota and Iowa. These outbreaks were less severe with no mortality.
Antigenic characterization established that all of the isolates were H3N2 influenza viruses related to the strains circulating in humans in 1997-98.
Sequence analysis of each of the gene segments of the H3N2 isolates revealed that they fall into two groups; the North Carolina isolate being distinguishable from the viruses from the other three states. Phylogenetic analysis indicates that the North Carolina isolate is a reassortant possessing genes encoding human-like H3N2 glycoproteins with the remaining gene segments from classical swine influenza virus. The isolates from TX, MN, IA are also reassortants possessing genes encoding similar human-like H3N2 glycoproteins but the "internal genes" were derived from classical swine and avian influenza viruses.
Discussion
The emergence of reassortant influenza viruses in pigs in the USA possessing genome segments originating from swine, human and avian influenza viruses illustrates continuing evolution of influenza viruses and the role of reassortment in nature. It remains to be determined whether these viruses will become established in the pig population of North America and whether they will represent an economic burden.
References
Acknowledgement
The H3N2 viruses were kindly provided by Kyoung-Jin Yoon, Iowa state veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory and Kurt Rossow, U of Minnesota Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory and in North Carolina. The studies were supported in part by Public Health research grant AI29680 and by the American Lebanese Syrian Associated Christies.
Influenza A H1N1 viruses isolated from pigs in Ireland are distinct from H1N1 viruses circulating in pigs in other European countries
Y.P. Lin, K.R. Cameron, M.S. Bennett, V. Gregory, A. Douglas, A.J. Hay, V. Regazzoli, *
P. Lenihan*
National Institute for Medical Research, The Ridgeway, Mill Hill, London, NW7 1AA.
* Department of Agriculture and Food, Central Veterinary Research Laboratory, Abbotstown, Castleknock, Dublin, 15, Ireland
Introduction
The predominant influenza A H1N1 viruses currently circulating in pigs in Europe have evolved from an avian virus introduced into pigs in 1979 (1). Genetic comparisons of avian-like H1N1 viruses isolated from pigs in southern China in 1993 indicated that they resulted from an independent introduction of an avian virus into pigs in Asia (2). H1N1 viruses isolated from pigs in Ireland since 1991, although antigenically related to the early European avian-like H1N1 viruses, are genetically distinct from those isolated during the same period in continental Europe. Phylogenetic analyses of the eight genes have indicated that they form a separate lineage from those of other European isolates and the H1N1 viruses isolated in southern China in 1993 and suggest that these viruses may also be the result of an independent introduction of an avian H1N1 virus into pigs in Ireland.
Results
Haemagglutination-inhibition (HI) tests using post-infection ferret antisera and monoclonal antibodies showed that the H1N1 viruses isolated in Ireland between 1992 and 1998 were antigenically related to, but distinguishable from, H1N1 reference viruses isolated in other European countries since 1979.
Comparison of the nucleotide sequences of HA genes showed that whereas the sequence encoding HA1s of recent 1997 Italian isolates differed by approximately 7 per cent from that of the early isolate, sw/Netherlands/3/80, the differences in sequence between the HA of the latter virus and those of recent Irish isolates were some two fold greater, approximately 14%, and similar to the divergence observed for the Hong Kong isolates such as sw/Hong Kong/168/93 (2). The divergence between the HAs of recent Irish and Italian viruses of approximately 19% was greater than between the HAs of Hong Kong and Irish viruses, isolated at about the same time (approximately 11%).
The sequences of the neuraminidase genes of the Irish viruses also differed to a greater extent (approximately 9%) than those of recent Italian viruses (approximately 6%) from the sequence a 1980 isolate, sw/OMS/2898/80, and have subsequently diverged further.
Comparative analyses of the other six genes indicated similar differences (approximately 2 fold) and divergence in the relationships between the early avian-like H1N1 viruses and the recent H1N1 isolates from Ireland or continental European countries. The two groups of viruses, however, share an unusual common property, amantadine resistance, due to substitution of serine 31 by asparagine in the M2 proteins of viruses isolated since about 1987.
Discussion
On the one hand, the H1N1 viruses isolated from pigs in Ireland are antigenically related to H1N1 viruses circulating in other European countries and both groups of viruses are resistant to amantadine, an unusual characteristic for natural influenza A virus isolates. On the other hand, the Irish viruses are genetically as divergent from those circulating in continental Europe as the viruses isolated from pigs in southern China. The available evidence is thus consistent with the independent introduction of avian H1N1 viruses into pigs in these three different geographical locations.
References
Description of serological results against several strains of influenza virus in a population of slaugterpigs in NW Spain
Oliveira,J.; Guitián,J.;Yus, E.; Sanjuán,M.L.
Infectious Diseases and Epidemiology, Veterinary College of Lugo, University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain
Introduction
Influenza virus (IV) type A has the capacity to infect man, birds, swine and some other animals. Birds are the most susceptible type of animals and which the virus is better adapted to. In birds the infection sometimes causes great disasters while in mammals the infection is usually less severe.
Since several years ago it has been proposed that IV would be able to shift from one species to another. Genetic and antigenic analysis carried out in virus isolated from several animals have showed important links within each other. The pig has been proposed as an animal that could play a key part in interspecies transmission especially from birds to man (1,2). This possibility would be greater if any variant of virus coming from birds could adapt and infect extensively to large pig populations. In this sense little research has been carried out to investigate the dissemination of the seroreactors in a large pig population against antigenic variants isolated from another species.
The goal of this study is to describe, at individual and at batch level, the extension of seropositivity against strains isolated from birds, humans and pigs in a large swine population.
Material and methods
During a six month period blood samples from slaughterpigs were collected in a slaughterhouse plant in NW Spain (Matadero Frigolouro, Pontevedra). The serum samples were kept at -20º C. until they were tested for the presence of antibodies against IV by IHA(3). Before testing by this serological technique and in order to eliminate the non-specific inhibitors against H1N1 and H3N2 subtypes all serum samples were heated at 56ºC. in a waterbath, adsorbed in chicken erythrocytes and treated with R.D.E.
A preliminary screening was made with the strains A/NJ/8/76 (H1N1) (NJ) and A/Victoria/1/75 (H3N2) (VIC). Every batch with one or more serum samples with a titre above 1:40 against such strains was considered as a seropositive batch. All samples of these seropositive batches were tested by IHA against A/sw/Netherlands/85 (H3N2) (NET), A/sw/Germany/91 (H1N1) (SW) an A/turkey/Germany/91 (H1N1) (TK ). IHA titres were converted to a logarithmic scale on base 2. A serum sample with a transformed titre >=3 (>=1:80) was considered positive.
The prevalence in each batch was computed as the number of seropositive samples divided by the total number of samples tested in a batch. Descriptive statistics for seroprevalence insight the batch against different strains were calculated only in batches with >=1 seropositive pigs.
Results
A total of 47 batches and 897 individual samples were serotested against all strains. The total number of seropositive samples against all H1N1 strains was higher than against H3N2 strains in samples tested by IHA (Table 1). In figure 1 we show the distribution of transformed titres against all strains in the samples tested. Table 2 shows descriptive statistics of the seroprevalence into pig batch. Mean and quartiles of the distribution of seroprevalences insight the batch against H1N1 variants was higher than against the strains H3N2.
Click here to see Figure 1: Distribution of titres against IV strains
Table 1: Serological results at individual level
|
Nº pos. samples |
Prevalence |
|
|
NJ |
297 |
33,11 |
|
SW |
253 |
28,21 |
|
TK |
408 |
45,48 |
|
VIC |
19 |
2,12 |
|
NET |
16 |
1,78 |
Table 2: Descriptive statistics of seroprevalence insight batch
|
Seroprevalence insight batch |
Nº batches |
Mean |
S.D. |
Mín |
Max |
25 |
Quar. 50 |
75 |
|
VIC |
9 |
17,5 |
16,4 |
2,9 |
50 |
7 |
10 |
28,3 |
|
NET |
8 |
21,7 |
17,9 |
2,5 |
60 |
10,3 |
18 |
30 |
|
SW |
35 |
43 |
31,2 |
2,9 |
100 |
17,5 |
30 |
66,7 |
|
NJ |
40 |
50,7 |
36,0 |
2 |
100 |
10,8 |
54 |
82,5 |
|
TK |
37 |
59,1 |
36,7 |
5 |
100 |
21 |
66,7 |
100 |
Discussion.
The results at individual level indicate that circulation of IV H3N2 was low while there was an important circulation of virus H1N1. These results are similar to other studies carried out some years ago (4).
The results showed in table 2 could be due to cross reactions between H3N2 and H1N1 but, since there is a low correlation between seroprevalence to strains H1N1and strains H3N2 both at individual and at group level (data not showed), this possibility is discarded. A possible biological explanation is that viruses H3N2 and H1N1have different patterns of circulation insight groups of pigs; so these results would suggest that the dissemination capacity of H1N1 virus is greater than H3N2 among the pig population studied. This greater circulation of H1N1 strains among pigs could increase the possibilities of such variants infecting to humans.
It is very difficult for the serologic results against H1N1 to be due to a poor elimination of non-specific inhibitors, since a sample was considered as positive only if transformed titre against a virus strain was >=3 and sera was treated to eliminate such non-specific inhibitors.
This study indicates that, in the swine population tested, probably strains with similar antigenic characteristics to H1N1 isolated from man and from birds have circulated. So pigs could be a reservoir of antigen variants of several viruses coming from different species.
This study was financially supported by Xunta of Galicia (Investigation project number Xuga 26105A95.)
We want to express our gratitude to Dr Claas and Dr. Scholtissek for providing us with recent isolates used in this study and to the Coren swine co-operative for its collaboration.
References
Seroprevalence of porcine influenza virus in Dutch weaning piglets
W.L.A. Loeffen*, G. Nodelijk, P.P. Heinen, L.A.M.G. van Leengoed, W.A. Hunneman*, J.H.M. Verheijden
*) Animal Health Service, Boxtel, The Netherlands
) Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Utrecht, The Netherlands
) Institute for Animal Science and Health (ID-DLO), Lelystad, The Netherlands
Introduction
During the winter of 1995/96 sixteen outbreaks of acute respiratory disease in finishing pigs were investigated1. Influenza turned out to be the major cause of these outbreaks. Seven outbreaks were due to primary influenza infections, while two others were concurrent with an infection with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae. Infections with influenza virus, resulting in outbreaks with clinical symptoms, occurred mostly at the age of 15 to 20 weeks. In acute sera, collected during the early stages of disease, no antibodies were present. In other groups of the same age antibodies were already present, indicating that infections with influenza virus may often occur at an earlier stage in life, possibly with little or no clinical signs.
Several studies were set up to determine the moments of infection in piglets and finishing pigs. This paper describes a longitudinal study into the course of maternal antibodies up to the age of ten weeks and a cross-sectional study into seroprevalences in weaning piglets. The aim of these studies was to determine a decay function for maternal antibodies and to estimate the incidence of influenza infections during the weaning period.
Materials and Methods
Two herds were included in the longitudinal study in piglets. In one herd, also participating in the cross-sectional study, blood samples were collected weekly in eight litters (five piglets each) from 1 to 10 weeks of age. In another herd, not participating in the cross-sectional study, blood samples were collected in ten litters (four piglets each) at the age of 3 days and 1, 2, 4, 6, 8 and 10 weeks. In both herds blood samples from the mothers of the piglets were also collected within one week after farrowing.
Thirty-two breeding herds with at least 100 sows were randomly selected from a Dutch database, containing all pig herds. All herds were visited twice, in October 1995 and March 1996. During each visit one compartment with piglets of 4-5 weeks old and one compartment with piglets of 8-9 weeks old were sampled. In each compartment approximately 17 to 22 blood samples were taken (dependent on the number of piglets in the compartment)2.
Since maternal antibodies turned out to be of major influence on the seroprevalence of eight to nine week old piglets, a mathematical method was used to correct for seroprevalence due to maternal antibodies. In short: based on the titers in the 4-5 week old group an estimate of the seroprevalence due to maternal antibodies in an 8-9 week old group in the same herd was calculated. This expected seroprevalence was compared to the true seroprevalence in the 8-9 weeks old group. Since the true seroprevalence was based on a random sample, a 95% confidence interval could be calculated also.
All blood samples were tested at the same time for antibodies against influenza H1N1 and H3N2, using a haemagglutination inhibition (HI) test. Virus strains used in the test were A/swine/Best/96 (H1N1) and A/Swine/St Oedenrode/96 (H3N2), both isolated during the above mentioned survey in 1995/961. All titers were log-transformed.
Results
Antibody titers of the sows and their piglets at the age of one week were positively correlated (Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.80-0.86 with a p<0.01 for influenza subtype H1N1 in both studies and H3N2 in the second study. For H3N2 in the first study, the correlation coefficient was only 0.54 with a p=0.17).
The linear model of the decay of maternal antibodies fitted very good for both subtypes H1N1 and H3N2. Explained variance for separate litters ranged from 0.93 to 0.99 for H1N1 and 0.78 to 0.99 for H3N2. Figure 1 shows an example of the decay for antibodies against H1N1 in the first longitudinal study. Both studies together resulted in a half-life of 12 days for both maternal H1N1 and H3N2 antibodies.
Click here to see Figure 1: Decay of maternal antibodies against influenza H1N1 in eight litters in the first longitudinal study.
In approximately one third of the herds the true seroprevalence was significantly higher than the expected seroprevalence, indicating a possible infection. This may however be an over-estimation, since there were also a few herds where the true seroprevalence was significantly lower than the expected seroprevalence (example in figure 2).
Click here to see Figure 2: Comparison of expected and true seroprevalence for antibodies against influenza H1N1 in 32 herds.
For individual piglets it was calculated that on average 16 to 17% of the piglets went through an infection with an influenza virus, resulting in an active immune response (for both subtypes separately)
Discussion
Log-transformed maternal antibody titers showed a linear decay, with a half-time of 12 days. Initial levels, depending on antibody titers in the sow and intake of colostrum, are therefor the most important factor in de duration of detectable amounts of maternal antibodies and, probably, the duration of protection against infection or at least clinical manifestation of an infection.
Although infections in weaning piglets occur, most piglets will enter the finishing facilities without antibodies against influenza or with maternal antibodies, still in decay.
The mathematical method used here will have to be evaluated. This will be done by testing blood samples from 8-9 week old piglets in a recently developed IgM-ELISA. The presence of IgM is an indication for a recent, active immune response.
References
This study was financially supported by Fort Dodge Animal Health in The Netherlands.
Outbreaks of influenza among fattening pigs
A.P. van Nieuwstadt, N. Stockhofe-Zurwieden, W. Loeffen, E. Kamp, J.C.de Jong
Institute for Animal Science and Health (ID-DLO), P.O.Box 65, NL-8200 AB LELYSTAD, The Netherlands
Animal Health Service, BOXTEL, The Netherlands
National Influenza Centre, Erasmus University, Rotterdam
Introduction.
Swine influenza is an acute respiratory disease caused by influenza virus type A, subtype H1N1 or H3N2. Outbreaks of respiratory disease due to influenza virus have occurred in the swine population of most West European countries since 1979. European H1N1 isolates are distinct from American strains, which are named classical swine influenza virus, and are more closely related to the virus that caused the severe influenza epidemic in humans in 1918, called the Spanish flu. Antgenically and genetically, European swine influenza virus isolates are closely related to the H1N1 isolates from ducks. Since 1984, infections with influenza virus subtype H3N2 also have been associated with outbreaks of respiratory disease in pigs. These H3N2 virus isolates from swine were antigenically very similar to the human Port Chalmers/1/73 strain. Serological surveys revealed that the H3N2 virus circulated in the swine population already at least ten years before clinical influenza in swine due to H3N2 virus infections was reported.
During the winter of 1995/96 we conducted a survey in 40 holdings of fattening pigs with a history of recurring respiratory disease for diagnosis of causative infectious agents. Sixteen outbreaks of respiratory disease were reported. Results showed that 7 outbreaks were caused by influenza virus and 5 were caused by Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae. No causative infectious agent could be unambiguously diagnosed in the other outbreaks. The results indicated that H1N1- and H3N2 virus infections were a major cause of acute respiratory disease in fattening pigs, which had not been expected. The results did raise questions about (1) extensiveness of circulation of influenza virus among fattening pigs; (2) whether influenza virus infections caused disease on their own without complicating secondary bacterial infections; (3) whether an antigenic drift of H1N1- or H3N2 virus had occurred, which would require an updating of virus strains in the vaccine.
Materials and Methods.
Forty herds with a history of recurring respiratory disease in fattening pigs were monitored during the winter of 1995/96. In these herds pigs were housed together at an age of 10 weeks in groups of 60 to 100 pigs. Stockholders were requested to notify early signs of respiratory disease such as increase of coughing, laboured breathing, and decrease of food intake. In this way 16 outbreaks of acute respiratory disease were reported to the veterinarian. From each outbreak 4 diseased pigs from a group with clear clinical signs were slaughtered for post mortem examination of the lungs, and 2 clinically healthy pigs of comparative age and origin from another group with no signs were slaughtered and served as controls. Lungs were examined for gross pathological lesions and tissue specimens were collected for histological examination and isolation of bacteria, viruses, and mycoplasmas. Acute and convalescent blood samples were collected from 10 groupmates in each outbreak. A 3rd blood sample was collected from the same pigs at the end of the fattening period. In addition, one or two other groups from the 16 holdings with a reported outbreak of respiratory disease were monitored serologically for influenza virus infections (27 groups in total). Blood from 10 pigs from each group was collected at the beginning and the end of the fattening period. Farmers who had reported a first outbreak of respiratory disease in their livestock were not requested to notify further outbreaks, so no clinical observations were available from those latter groups.
Results.
Seven out of 16 outbreaks of acute respiratory disease were diagnosed as influenza. These influenza outbreaks occurred 5 to 10 weeks after pigs were grouped together for fattening. In 5 outbreaks H1N1 virus was isolated from pneumonic lung lesions of all 4 diseased pigs that were necropsied and diagnosis was confirmed by a seroconversion of all 10 groupmates in a HAI test with H1N1 virus. In 2 other groups a H3N2 virus infection was diagnosed by virus isolation from the lungs and diagnosis was confirmed serologically. First signs of an outbreak were fever, prostration, apathy, and anorexia in 10 to 30% of pigs in the affected group. At necropsy a multifocal catarrhal pneumonia was observed, which was frequently associated with parenchymal haemorrhages and affected 10 to 50% of the lung tissue. Histological examination revealed necrotizing endobronchitis/bronchiolitis accompanied by broncho-interstitial inflammation and sero-fibrinous exudation and haemorrhages into the alveolar space. Similar lesions were observed in 7 of 14 control pigs, but lesions were much less severe. Influenza virus was isolated from lungs of 5 control pigs. Pathogenic bacteria were isolated from 15 out of 28 lungs of diseased pigs, but we never isolated the same species from all 4 pigs of the same outbreak.. Species isolated were Haemophilus parasuis, Bordetella bronchiseptica, Pasteurella multocida, Streptococcus suis, and (from one pig only) Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae. In 13 pigs influenza was not complicated by a secondary bacterial infection, as no pathogenic bacteria could be isolated from the lungs.
Serological examination revealed extensive circulation of H1N1 virus during the fattening period in 20 of 43 groups (46.5%; the 16 groups with a reported outbreak were included) and of H3N2 virus in 9 groups (21%). Because no HAI antibodies were detected in blood samples collected at the beginning and the end of the fattening period, we concluded that no H1N1 virus circulated in 4 groups, and no H3N2 virus circulated in 11 groups. In the remaining groups, a few pigs or not any showed a significant rise of HAI antibody titre, but most pigs had antibodies in the first blood sample either indicating an earlier infection during the breeding period or a subclinical infection in the first few weeks of the fattening period.
Recent isolates of H1N1 virus [Infl A/swine/Neth/Best/96 (H1N1)] and H3N2 virus [Infl A/swine/Neth/St.Oedenrode/96 (H3N2)] were used as a HA antigen in the HAI test. A few convalescent sera were also tested with older isolates of H1N1- and H3N2 virus from swine, and HAI antibody titres were not much different. However, with the human Port Chalmers/1/73 (H3N2) strain antibody titres were significantly lower than with the St. Oedenrode/96 strain.
Conclusions.
Influenza virus infections are a major cause of respiratory disease in fattening pigs. Influenza virus infections are often complicated by secondary bacterial infections, but an influenza virus infection can be the primary and single cause of a pneumonia.
Clinical signs of influenza are not pathognomic, and an infection with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae has to be considered in clinical differential diagnosis. At gross pathological examination, the two infections can be distinguished, however. An infection with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae causes a necrotizing haemorrhagic fibrinous pleuropneumonia.
There are indications of an antigenic drift of porcine H3N2 virus, by which antigenic relatedness with the human Port Chalmers/1/73 strain was lost.
This study was financially supported by Intervet International, Boxmeer, The Netherlands
Seroprevalence of influenza virus among wild boars in Poland
Iwona Markowska-Daniel, Zygmunt Pejsak
National Veterinary Research Institute, Swine Diseases Department, 57 Partyzantow Str., 24-100 Pulawy, Poland
Introduction
Swine influenza is an acute infectious, respiratory diseases of swine caused by type A influenza viruses belonging to the Family Orthomyxoviridae, genus Influenzavirus. The disease is characterized by sudden onset, coughing, dyspnea, fever and rapid recovery.
The aim of the study was to determine the prevalence of porcine and human Influenza A virus (subtypes H1N1 and H3N2) among domestic pigs and wild boar populations in Poland.
Materials and methods
3945 blood samples from animals raised in large farms located in 48 provinces (out of 49) of Poland were tested. Also blood samples from heart or pleural cavity, were collected from 440 hunted wild boars of unknown age, during the period January-November 1998 in 42 provinces of Poland. Samples of sera were stored at 20oC prior to testing.
Two virus strains of different subtypes were used in this study: H1N1 (strain A/Sw/Bel/1/83, at a titer EID50 107.5/ml) and H3N2 (strain A/Sw/Gent/1/84, at a titer EID50 106.5/ml). The viruses were grown in the allantoic and amniotic cavities of 10-day-old embryonated SPF chicken eggs.
As a control of haemagglutination inhibition assay the reference sera for H1N1 subtype, at a titer 512 and for H3N2 subtype, at a titer 2560 were included.
RDE (receptor destroying enzyme) (Sigma) of Vibrio comma was used for elimination of non-specific inhibitors of haemagglutination.
Serum antibodies to influenza virus were detected by the haemagglutination inhibition assay (HI) according to standard procedure. The sera were heat - treated at 56oC for 30 min. During the next step the sera were adsorbed with 50% (v/v) chicken erytrocytes (RBC) to remove non-specific haemagglutinins for 1 hr at 4oC. Sera tested for seroconversion for H3N2 subtype were additionally treated with 100 U/ml RDE, overnight at 37oC, followed by the inactivation at 56oC for 30 min. In each test the necessary serum, virus and red blood cells controls were included. HI tests were done using 4 haemagglutinating units (HAU) of each virus and 0.5% (v/v) RBC. Owing to the different treatment of the sera, the initial serum dilutions were 1:4 against H1N1 influenza virus and 1:20 against H3N2 influenza virus. In microassay HI titer was taken as the reciprocal of the highest mean antibody dilution inhibiting 4 HAU of virus. To facilitate reading exact end-points the plates were slanted so that non-agglutinated cells flew freely as a tear drop. As a positive results the haemagglutynin titer „ 1:8 and „ 1:40, respectively for H1N1 and H3N2 strains was estimated.
Results
The monitoring study showed the occurrence of influenza virus among pigs and wild boars. Antibodies specific to subtype H1N1 were detected in 35% of sera from pigs and 24.1% of sera from wild boars. A serological survey for the subtype H3N2 demonstrated 29.3% and 6.8% of seropositives, respectively among pigs and wild boars. It should be stressed that the subtype H1N1 of SIV circulate at high frequency among swine as well as wild boars in the West of Poland while H3N2 subtype is circulating particularly in the East of Poland.
The titer against H1N1 strain of influenza virus in the most sera was below 1:8; 395 out of 3945 tested sera (10%) have the titer >1:16, and 258 sera (6.5%) the titer above >1:32.
The seroconversion for H3N2 virus strain and the estimated titers were similar. 675 sera (17.1%) was characterized by the titer >1:40, a titer > 1:160 was estimated only in 158 cases (4%). 484 of pigs sera (12.3%) and 17 wild boars sera (3.9%) reacted with both tested antigens.
Tab.1
Presence of antibodies against influenza virus in domestic pigs and wild boars
|
Number of sera |
Number / % positive sera |
||
|
H1N1 |
H3N2 |
H1N1 and H3N2 |
|
|
3945 (pigs) |
1380/35,0 |
1158/29,3 |
484/12,3 |
|
440 (wild boars) |
106/24,1 |
30/6,8 |
17/3,9 |
Discussion
Infections of domestic swine with H1N1 virus were described in France, England, Germany, Thailand and Japan. In our study we reported that epizootiological situation of pig herds in Poland in field of swine influenza is similar to the situation in neighboring countries. It was shown by the German authors that for different strains of influenza virus with antigenic pattern of H1N1 the percentage of seroreagents among tested swine ranged from 24% to 32 %, with the exception for the A/Singapore/6/86 strain, which caused the seroconversion in 3% of the animals only. A slightly less intense spreading was noted in humans for the strains SIV of H3N2 pattern, with the seroconversion with various studied strains estimated for 10-23% by the authors mentioned above. Moreover, these authors found that of the animals examined approx. 10% exhibited the antibodies against both antigenic types of the influenza virus. Similar studies were performed by Brown et al. in Great Britain. Positive results of serological investigation in regard to strains H1N1 were obtained in approx. 26% of the sera evaluated. A marked spreading of the infection with subtype H3N2 was found, with the presence of seroreagents at the level of 39%. The study performed by Madec et al. involved reproductive swine herds in the northern region of France (Bretany), where all the major centers of pig husbandry are located. The above mentioned authors found that until 1981 year the swine population was infected with the influenza virus to the minimal degree. In the forthcoming year the number of infected herds increased up to approx. 50%.
Summarizing, it might be stated that epizootiological situation concerning SI in Poland and other European countries intensively producing pigs is similar.
References
Haemagglutination inhibition titers of swine sera against influenza virus isolates from '98 and from '83-'84
K. Gillis, K. Van Reeth and M. Pensaert
Laboratory of Virology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Gent, Belgium
Introduction
Influenza viruses are subject to antigenic variation. This has two important implications. First, immune subjects may be incompletely protected against more recent drift variants. Second, antibodies against recent strains may react to a lower degree when tested against older strains in haemagglutination inhibition (HI) tests.
The evolution of swine influenza viruses has been followed less intensively than that of human and equine viruses. In this study we examined whether recent swine sera from the field show different reactivity against strains from '83-'84 and strains from '98 in HI tests.
Material and Methods
The H1N1 influenza viruses used were:
A/New Jersey/8/76, Sw/Belgium/1/83 1, and Sw/Belgium/1/98. The H3N2 viruses included were: A/Port Chalmers/1/73, Sw/Ukkel/1/84 2, and Sw/Flanders/1/98. While A/New Jersey/8/76 and A/Port Chalmers/1/73 are included in most vaccines for swine, Sw/Belgium/1/83 and Sw/Ukkel/1/84 are used in routine haemagglutination inhibition test in the authors' laboratory. Sw/Belgium/1/98 and Sw/Flanders/1/98 were isolated in '98. All viruses were at the fourth passage in embryonated eggs.
Cross-HI tests with monospecific swine sera
All viruses were characterized in HI tests with monospecific swine sera. To obtain a monospecific antiserum for each specific isolate, gnotobiotic piglets were inoculated intratracheally with 107.5 EID50 of the respective strain. Sera were collected 62 days post inoculation. Haemagglutination inhibition tests were performed as described earlier 3.
Comparative HI tests of recent field sera using older and recent virus strains
The '83-'84 and '98 isolates were included in HI-test against recent field sera collected from a total of 30 pigs on 3 different fattening farms (10 pigs per farm).
Results
Cross-HI tests with H1N1 strains demonstrated that the recent isolate Sw/Belgium/1/98 reacts with antisera against the strains from '76 and '83 (Table 1). On the other hand, the serum against the '98 strain revealed at least 32-fold lower antibody titers against the older isolates than against the homologous strain.
For the H3N2 strains, the recent Sw/Flanders/1/98 isolate reacts with antisera against both older isolates (Table 1). In the antiserum against the '98 strain, the antibody titers against the isolates from '73 and '84 are at least 8-fold lower than those against the homologous strain.
Table 1: Cross-HI tests with selected strains
|
HI titer in sera against |
|||||||||||||
|
Virus |
A/NJ/ 8/76 |
Sw/Belg/ 1/83 |
Sw/Belg/ 1/98 |
A/PC/ 1/73 |
Sw/Ukkel/ 1/84 |
Sw/Fl/ 1/98 |
|||||||
|
H1N1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
|
A/New Jersey/8/76 |
128 |
32 |
8 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
|||||||
|
Sw/Belgium/1/83 |
4 |
64 |
16 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
|||||||
|
Sw/Belgium/1/98 |
32 |
128 |
512 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
|||||||
|
H3N2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
|
A/Port Chalmers/1/73 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
320 |
2560 |
<40 |
|||||||
|
Sw/Ukkel/1/84 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
160 |
2560 |
80 |
|||||||
|
Sw/Flanders/1/98 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
160 |
1280 |
640 |
|||||||
In the comparative HI tests with the H1N1 isolates 100%, 100%, and 90% of the animals of farms A, B, and C respectively, test positive with the recent Sw/Belgium/1/98 strain. These percentages are 80%, 50% and 30% when the tests are performed with Sw/Belgium/1/83 (Table 2). Sera which tested positive for both strains show 8 to 16 times higher titers against the recent strain.
For the H3N2 strains 30%, 60%, and 90% of the animals are found positive on the respective farms when tested with the recent Sw/Flanders/1/98 strain (Table 3). On these farms 0%, 40%, and 50% of the sera are positive against the Sw/Ukkel/1/84 strain. If a serum is positive for both H3N2 strains, antibody titers are up to 8 times higher for the '98 strain compared to the Sw/Ukkel/1/84 strain.
Table 2: H1N1 antibody titers in field sera from '98 in HI tests with isolates from '83 and from '98
|
|
HI titers in serum no. |
||||||||||
|
Farm |
Virus |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
|
A |
Sw/Belg/1/83 |
16 |
<4 |
16 |
32 |
4 |
<4 |
64 |
32 |
32 |
16 |
|
|
Sw/Belg/1/98 |
256 |
128 |
256 |
256 |
256 |
128 |
1024 |
2048 |
2048 |
512 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B |
Sw/Belg/1/83 |
<4 |
32 |
64 |
8 |
128 |
64 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
|
|
Sw/Belg/1/98 |
64 |
1024 |
2048 |
256 |
1024 |
1024 |
256 |
64 |
16 |
64 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C |
Sw/Belg/1/83 |
<4 |
8 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
8 |
<4 |
<4 |
<4 |
4 |
|
|
Sw/Belg/1/98 |
16 |
256 |
8 |
4 |
<4 |
128 |
64 |
4 |
32 |
64 |
Table 3: H3N2 antibody titers in field sera from '98 in HI tests with isolates from '84 and from '98
|
|
HI titers in serum no. |
||||||||||
|
Farm |
Virus |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
|
A |
Sw/Ukkel/1/84 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
|
|
Sw/Fl/1/98 |
<40 |
<40 |
40 |
80 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
80 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
B |
Sw/Ukkel/1/84 |
<40 |
<40 |
<40 |
640 |
160 |
40 |
<40 |
640 |
<40 |
<40 |
|
|
Sw/Fl/1/98 |
40 |
<40 |
<40 |
640 |
320 |
320 |
<40 |
320 |
<40 |
80 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
C |
Sw/Ukkel/1/84 |
<40 |
40 |
40 |
80 |
<40 |
<40 |
40 |
<40 |
80 |
<40 |
|
|
Sw/Fl/1/98 |
160 |
160 |
160 |
160 |
80 |
160 |
80 |
160 |
320 |
<40 |
Discussion and conclusions
These results clearly demonstrate that the number of animals detected depends on the virus strain used in the HI test. Although the underlying cause was not determined in this study, antigenic drift can be put forward.
In conclusion, these preliminary results indicate that the virus strain used in haemagglutination inhibition tests for serology should frequently be tested for its ability to detect seropositive animals and, if needed, be updated. In the future more swine influenza virus strains will be compared in HI tests to validate these findings.
References
Research on influenza in horses and pigs in the Czech Republic*
Z. Pospísil, P. Lány, D. Zendulková, B. Tumová§, P. Jahn, P. Cíhal
University of Veterinary and Pharmaceutical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Palackého 1-3, 612 42 Brno, Czech Republic
§
National Institute of Public Health, _robárova 48, 100 42 Prague, Czech RepublicIntroduction
In the Czech Republic, research on animal influenza has had a long tradition. An equine influenza virus, which later became a reference prototype strain for the subtype 1, was isolated as early as in 1956 (1) and designated A/equi1/Prague/56 (H7N7). Swine influenza has also received considerable attention, as shown by a number of papers published on its aetiology, pathogenesis and immune response in pigs, adaptation of human influenza strains to piglets, etc. (2,3,).
In the mid-1970s, however, the systematic studies of influenza viruses were discontinued. Since, in horses, new epizootics continued to appear in our country and an equine influenza virus, subtype 2, had earlier been identified abroad, research on equine influenza was, at least partially, resumed at the end of the 1980s. After new variants of avian-like H1N1 influenza A virus isolated from pigs in Western Europe was reported (4) studies on swine influenza were also renewed.
Material and methods
For virus isolation, nasal swabs were collected from diseased animals during epizootics and the virus was cultivated in chick embryos.
Specific antibodies against selected number of reference strains of equine, swine and human influenza viruses were assayed in the haemagglutination-inhibiton test. In view of the fact that new variants of avian-like H1N1 influenza A virus were isolated from pigs, the examination also included A/sw/Germany/91 and A/sw/Italy45/79 influenza viruses. To remove non specific haemagglutinins, sera were in addition to inactivation at 560 C for 30 minutes, pretreated with a) kaolin and absorbtion with chicken or guinea pig erythrocytes, b) receptor destroying enzyme (RDE) or c) potassium periodate.
Sequencing of the HA1 portion of the haemagglutinin gene in one of our isolates (A/equi 2/M-2/92) was carried out in the laboratory of the Animal Health Trust, Newmarket, UK.
Results
During outbreaks of equine influenza infection at the end of the 1980s and in the mid-1990s, many strains classified as A/equi 2 (H3N8), were isolated (5, 6). The detailed characterisation based on the haemagglutination-inhibition test with specific immune sera against selected A/equi 2 subtype viruses revealed that antigenic properties of our 1995 isolates differed considerably from the Miami/63 strain but were similar to Newmarket 10/76 and our Brno 2/89 isolates. Using monoclonal antibodies, these isolates were identified as belonging to the group with the Miami HC 1 subtype. When the results of sequencing of the HA 1 portion of the HA gene were compared they revealed considerable differences between the recent isolates from our and other foreign laboratories and the previously isolated strains. In comparison with all the other strains, our isolate had a unique substitution at position 156 in a sequence of 329 amino acids studied.
In porcine populations, neither influenza virus nor specific antibody were isolated which would indicate the presence of A/sw (H1N1) influenza virus infection. On the other hand, porcine sera showed antibodies against the human A/Praha 625/95 (H3N2) influenza virus isolated during a human influenza epidemic which occurred in the Czech Republic in December 1995. While in December 1995, all porcine sera gave negative results, in January 1996 HI antibody titres ranged from 1:80 to 1:160. In April 1995, the average titres fell to values of about 1:20 and, by June 1996, the sera were antibody free(Fig.1).
Discussion
Examinations based on serological and molecular biology methods showed that equine influenza viruses isolated in the Czech Republic in 1995 were most similar to European isolates from the turn of the 80s and 90s. This may be accounted for by limited contacts between our and West European horses at that time.
The dynamics of antibody titres in porcine sera showed that during the human influenza epidemics pig herds became infected, with the subsequent antibody response, but the virus did not adopt in them and gradually disappierd in the following 6 month. This is supported by a retrospective search concerning the pig herd health status; during or after the human influenza epidemics, farmers did not notice any signs indicating the spread of influenza infection in their herds.
After antibodies against human influenza virus were detected in pigs, some samples of sera collected from horses of different herds in the 1995-1997 period were also tested. Several of them showed haemagglutination-inhibiting antibodies against the A/Shangdong 93 (H3N2) influenza virus. However, since H3 haemagglutinins of human and equine origin are known to cross-react, it is difficult to make any conclusion without the evidence of human influenza infection being confirmed or excluded by specific methods including the neuraminidase inhibition test.
Click here to see Figure 1: Titres of antibodies in pig sera against the humane influenza virus.
References
*
Supported by the Grant Agency of the Czech Republic (Grant No. 508/95/0183 and 524/99/1226).A review of avian influenza
D.J. Alexander
VLA Weybridge, Addlestone, Surrey, United Kingdom
Aetiology
A disease capable of causing extremely high mortality amongst infected fowls was first defined in 1878 and became known as 'fowl plague'. The causative organism of this disease was shown to be a virus as early as 1901 but it was not until 1955 that the relationship of this and other milder viruses isolated from birds with mammalian influenza A viruses (first isolated in the 1930s) was demonstrated (1). Only type A influenza viruses are known to cause natural infections of birds, but viruses of all 15 HA and all 9 NA influenza A subtypes in the majority of possible combinations have been isolated from avian species.
Avian influenza pathogenicity
Influenza A viruses infecting poultry can be divided into two distinct groups on the basis of their ability to cause disease. The very virulent viruses cause fowl plague, now termed highly pathogenic avian influenza [HPAI], in which mortality may be as high as 100%. These viruses have been restricted to subtypes H5 and H7, although not all viruses of these subtypes cause HPAI. All other viruses cause a much milder, primarily respiratory, disease, which may be exacerbated by other infections or environmental conditions.
The haemagglutinin glycoprotein for influenza viruses is produced as a precursor, HA0, which requires post translational cleavage by host proteases before it is functional and virus particles are infectious (2). The HA0 precursor proteins of avian influenza viruses of low virulence for poultry have a single arginine at the cleavage site and are limited to cleavage by host proteases such as trypsin-like enzymes and thus restricted to replication at sites in the host where such enzymes are found, i.e. the respiratory and intestinal tracts. HPAI viruses possess multiple basic amino acids [arginine and lysine] at their HA0 cleavage sites and appear to be cleavable by a ubiquitous protease[s] probably one or more proprotein-processing subtilisin-related endoproteases of which furin is the leading candidate (3). These viruses are able to replicate throughout the bird, damaging vital organs and tissues which results in disease and death.
Ecology.
Wild birds.
The first isolation of influenza virus from feral birds was in 1961 from common terns (Sterna hirundo) in South Africa (4), but it was not until the mid-1970s that any systematic investigation of influenza in feral birds was undertaken. These revealed the enormous pools of influenza viruses now known to be present in the wild bird population.
Virus isolations from other wild birds have been completely overshadowed by the number, variety and widespread distribution of influenza viruses in waterfowl, Order Anseriformes. In the surveys listed by Stallknecht and Shane (5) a total of 21,318 samples from all species resulted in the isolation of 2,317 (10.9%) viruses. Of these samples 14,303 were from birds of the Order Anseriformes and yielded 2,173 (15.2%) isolates. The next highest isolation rates were 2.9% and 2.2% from the Passeriformes and Charadriiformes and the overall isolation rate from all birds other than ducks and geese was 2.1%.
Caged 'pet' birds.
Since 1975 when the first isolates from caged birds were recorded, isolates, from all sources, have been mainly of H4 or H3 subtypes. The majority of influenza viruses from caged birds come from passerine species and only rarely are psittacines infected. Although the presence of influenza viruses in birds held in quarantine is monitored continually in several countries around the world, there appear to have been periods, often lasting several years when no isolations have been made.
Domestic poultry.
Since 1959 primary outbreaks of HPAI in poultry have been reported 17 times, five in turkeys and 12 in turkeys; 8 of these outbreaks have occurred since 1990 (Table 1).
Table 1. Reported HPAI isolates from poultry since 1959
| A/chicken/Scotland/59 (H5N1) |
| A/turkey/England/63 (H7N3) |
| A/turkey/Ontario/7732/66 (H5N9) |
| A/chicken/Victoria/76 (H7N7) |
| A/chicken/Germany/79 (H7N7) |
| A/turkey/England/199/79 (H7N7) |
| A/chicken/Pennsylvania/1370/83 (H5N2) |
| A/turkey/Ireland/1378/83 (H5N8) |
| A/chicken/Victoria/85 (H7N7) |
| A/turkey/England/50-92/91 (H5N1) |
| A/chicken/Victoria/1/92 (H7N3) |
| A/chicken/Queensland/667-6/94 (H7N3) |
| A/chicken/Mexico/8623-607/94 (H5N2) |
| A/chicken/Pakistan/447/94 (H7N3) |
| A/chicken/NSW/97 (H7N4) |
| A/chicken/Hong Kong/97 (H5N1) |
| A/chicken/Italy/330/97 (H5N2) |
During 1994-99 infections of poultry with influenza viruses of H9N2 subtype appear to have been common world-wide. Outbreaks occurred in Germany in 1995-96, Italy in 1994, Ireland in 1997, South Africa in 1995, and Korea in 1996 (6). Since 1997 serious problems associated with H9N2 virus have been reported in Iran, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, China and other Asian countries.
Chickens.
At the end of the 19th and early 20th Centuries fowl plague was often reported in chickens and in several countries this disease was probably enzootic. However, in the second half of the 20th Century reports of influenza infections of chickens have been rare compared to infections of other domestic poultry despite the much higher populations of chickens. For example in the USA, despite frequent influenza epizootics in turkeys in some states, between 1964 and 1982 only three outbreaks in chickens were recorded (7).
Despite the low incidence of influenza infections of chickens throughout the world there have been 12 outbreaks of HPAI since 1959 and significant spread occurred in Pennsylvania and neighbouring states in the USA during 1983-1984 and in Mexico and Pakistan in 1994/95. Other outbreaks since 1959 have shown no or extremely limited spread. Eight HPAI outbreaks in backyard poultry flocks infected with H5N2 virus were reported in Italy in 1997/8. Outbreaks of H5N1 HPAI occurred on three farms in Hong Kong during March-May 1997 with 70-100% mortalities (8) and subsequent spread to live bird markets.
Turkeys.
Since 1963, most of the major turkey-producing countries have had disease problems associated with influenza infections. In the USA in California and Minnesota, where turkey farms are heavily concentrated and situated on migratory waterfowl flyways, influenza virus infections have been seen regularly, but in other countries outbreaks in turkeys have been usually restricted to one or two isolated incidents in the years recorded. Despite the greater prevalence of influenza viruses in turkeys, of the 17 reported isolations of HPAI since 1959 only five were apparently primarily from turkeys (Table 1).
Commercial ducks.
The influenza status of commercial ducks in most countries is poorly understood or has not been investigated. When surveillance of commercial ducks has been undertaken, enormous pools of virus and many subtype combinations have been detected.
Ratites.
The increase in trade in ostriches and other ratites during the 1990s led to the movement of large numbers of such birds around the world and the testing for viruses, including influenza, has resulted in the regular isolation of influenza viruses from these birds. Since the first reported isolations of influenza viruses from ratites in 1991 viruses of H3N2, H4N2, H4N6, H5N2, H5N9, H7N1, H7N3, H9N2, H10N4 and H10N7 subtypes have been isolated. All these were of low virulence for chickens.
Other domestic poultry.
Other commercially reared birds represent a very small proportion of domestic poultry in most countries. Some such birds (e.g. pheasants and geese) are reared under semi-wild conditions. Isolations of influenza viruses have been reported from muscovy ducks (Cairinia moschata), mallard ducks (Anas platyrhyncos), pheasants (Phasianus spp.), Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica), chukars (Alectoris chukar), guinea fowl (Numida meleagris), and various types of goose.
References
Evolution of avian influenza viruses
David Suarez
Southeast Poultry Research Laboratory, USDA-ARS Athens, Georgia, U.S.A.
Influenza viruses have been known to infect a wide variety of animals, but it predominantly occurs in humans, swine, horses and avian species. However, the natural hosts and primary reservoir for influenza viruses are thought to be wild waterfowl and shorebirds, and mammals and poultry are not thought to be normal hosts for the virus. When influenza virus does cross over from its wildlife reservoir to an abnormal host, and presumably to a host that it is not well adapted to, the virus will begin to adapt and evolve in the new host.
The rapid evolutionary changes in endemic influenza virus in humans, swine, and horses have been well described for the hemagglutinin, nucleoprotein and nonstructural genes. This is in contrast to influenza viruses in waterfowl, where the viruses appear to be evolving slowly. Until recently it has been unclear if influenza viruses in poultry were more like endemic mammalian viruses with rapid evolutionary changes or like waterfowl with slow evolutionary changes. The recent outbreaks in Mexico with a H5 influenza virus and in the live bird markets (LBM) in the Northeast United States with a H7 influenza outbreak have demonstrated that influenza viruses have high rates of evolutionary change in chickens (1,2). To be able to measure an evolutionary rate, you must have the assumption that all the viruses compared are in the same virus lineage, and in poultry this means that an outbreak is from a single introduction of virus. The recent observations about evolution of influenza in poultry is the result of extensive sampling of an influenza outbreak in chickens over multiple years. Previous efforts to determine if influenza in poultry had a high evolutionary rate had been based on observations from a number of unrelated outbreaks, and you cannot compare evolutionary rates from isolates from unrelated outbreaks. The Mexican and U.S. LBM outbreaks provided the first opportunity to examine in depth an extended avian influenza outbreak in chickens. In both outbreaks the measured nucleotide subtitutions/site/year were similar to what has been observed in mammalian species (Figure 1).
Comparisons between influenza viruses from different poultry and even mammalian outbreaks can be better compared when they are observed in context to the original source of virus, waterfowl and shorebirds. Nucleotide consensus sequences can be made of available avian influenza isolates for several different genes, including the hemagglutinin, matrix, nonstructural and nucleoprotein genes. Because of the nucleotide phylogenetic clustering of isolates into North American (NA) and Eurasian (EA) lineages, separate consensus sequences need to be made for each group. When these consensus nucleotide sequences are translated into an amino acid sequences, the NA and EA differences disappear for most gene segments (Table 1), suggesting that influenza viruses are well adapted to the waterfowl host.
Table 1
Comparison of Consensus Eurasian and North American Avian Influenza Virus Sequences
|
# Nucleotide |
% |
# AA |
% |
|
|
Nonstrucural A |
890 |
95.7 |
||
|
NS1 |
230 |
100 |
||
|
NS2 |
121 |
100 |
||
|
Matrix |
1027 |
94.8 |
||
|
M1 |
252 |
100 |
||
|
M2 |
97 |
99 |
||
|
NP |
1565 |
92.9 |
498 |
99.7 |
|
H5 |
996 |
83.1 |
332 |
93.1 |
When doing pairwise comparisons of the consensus sequence to each influenza isolate, you will generate data that has a normal distribution. In other words, avian influenza isolates differ in the number of nucleotide or aa differences from the consensus with most isolates being within two standard deviations from the mean number of differences. Some isolates do not fall within two deviations from the mean, and those that dont correlate with viruses that have been in abnormal hosts for an extended period of time, i.e. humans, swine and horses. For the Mexican and U.S. L.B.M. isolates, although still within two standard deviations of the mean, the earliest isolates are closest to the mean and the most recent isolates are farthest from the mean. These observations allow us to make predictions when looking at outbreaks from only a single time point. For example, in the Hong Kong H5 outbreak, although multiple isolates have been made, they were recovered in a span of less than one year. These isolates when compared to the consensus data and other isolates show that for most genes they fall outside of two standard deviations from the mean as demonstrated graphically in figure 2. This suggests two possibilities. The first is that these isolates are at the normal extreme for what will be observed. The second possibility is that the H5 viruses had been adapting for several years to poultry and had evolved away from the avian influenza consensus. The second possibility appears more likely in explaining why the Hong Kong H5 viral genes were not closely related to any other sequenced influenza viral genes.
Click here to see Figure 2: Phylogenetic tree of NS1 protein of Eurasian avian and avian-like influenza virus isolates.
References
Susceptibility of a newborn swine kidney (NSK) cell line to several influenza virus types
M. Ferraria, E. Fonia, P. Ajmone-Marsanb, L. Moltenic, M.N. Losioa, C. Pinonia, R. Vassallia.
a
Istituto Zooprofilattico Sperimentale, Brescia, Italy; bIstituto di Zootecnica, Università degli Studi di Piacenza, Italy; cIstituto di Zootecnica, Università degli Studi di Milano, Italy.Introduction
Influenza is a respiratory disease affecting humans and several animal species all over the world. Prevention of this annual seasonal disease in humans can be achieved by vaccination which is carried out by using particular recombinant virus strains which contain the antigenic determinants of the virus type selected during the most recent epidemics. Traditionally, influenza virus propagation is performed in chicken embryos known to be the laboratory biological system of choice. However, recently, several disadvantages concerning their use have been found, such as the ncessity of specific pathogen free (SPF) eggs, the time consuming process for their manipulation and the need to purify virus proteins to avoid anaphylactic reactions in the host (1). Moreover, it has been recently shown that the antigenic characteristics of the viruses grown in eggs are different from the original field samples (2). Accordingly, cell cultures seem to be the most promising biological system alternative to chicken embryos because they can be easily manipulated, tested in their charateristics, they are a reproducible system for virus propagation and maintain the original antigenic features of the field virus (3).
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the properties of a new established cell lines of newborn swine kidney origin, and to evaluate its susceptibility to influenza virus types.
Material and Methods
Cell cultures and media
Primary cell cultures, from kidneys of a two day-old swine, were prepared by standard techniques. Subpassages were made twice a week and the cells, which were epithelial-like from about the 10th passage, were serially propagated at 1:3 ratio. The cell line was referred to as NSK (newborn swine kidney) and its biological features were determined on a stock prepared at the 70th passage level. The Madin Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cell line was used as a reference cell line for influenza virus growth.
Both cell systems were propagated in MEM enriched with fetal calf serum (fcs) (10% v/v) and containing the usual antibiotics. For virus infection the concentration of fcs in MEM was reduced to 3% (v/v). Influenza virus propagation in NSK and MDCK cells was performed in MEM enriched with trypsin (10 m g / ml) and fcs (0.5%, v/v).
NSK cell characterization
The following tests were made :
determination of the contaminants, growth curve and plating efficiency, tumorigenicity, kariology, species of origin by DNA fingerprinting and isoenzyme analysis.
Virus susceptibility
The study was carried out with several viruses causing infections in pigs (table 1) and with influenza virus types which had been isolated from different species (table 2). The latter were also propagated in MDCK cells.
Viral replication was determined by evaluation of cytopathic effect (CPE) and by immunofluorescence assay (IFA) for (HCV). Infectious and haemmaglutination titres were also evaluated.
Table 1. Viruses causing infections in pigs
|
Pseudorabies virus (PRV) |
|
Pig parvovirus (PPV) |
|
Hog cholera virus (HCV) |
|
Pig reproductive respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) |
|
Transmissible gastroenteritis of swine (TGEV) |
|
Encephalomyocarditis virus (ECMV) |
|
Swine vesicular disease virus (SVSV) |
|
Enteroviruses |
Table 2. Influenza virus types
|
A/swine SW/OMS/ 2899/82 (H1N1); SW/OMS/3633/84 (H3N2) |
|
A/aves (H6N2), (H9N2), PD/97 (H5N2) |
|
A/human/PR/13/94 (H3N2), SD/ 9/93 (H3N2), TW/6/86 (H1N1) |
|
B/human |
|
1/equine/Praga/56 (H7N7) |
|
2/equine/Miami/63 (H3N8), Suffolk/89 (H3N8), Newmarket/2/93 (H3N8) |
Results
The NSK cell line appeared to be free of contaminants (bacteria, fungi, yeasts, mycoplasma and pestiviruses); it reached the highest cell concentration 96 hours after seeding and showed a plating efficiency of 3.25%. No tumorigenic property was detected either by in vitro tests or following the inoculation into nude mice. The chromosomal number was 36. Finally, the origin species was confirmed by DNA fingerprinting and by the isoenzyme migration pattern which were similar to those of the reference pig kidney cell cultures.
Most of the viruses causing infections in pigs replicated in the NSK cell line from the first passage whereas TGE virus growth was detected from the 4th passage. Only PRRS agent didnt grow in this new cell line.
Furthermore, NSK cell line appeared to be susceptible to all the influenza types from swine, aves, and humans, while only the 2/Miami/63 and 2/Suffolk/89 viruses from equine species replicated in the NSK cells. Moreover, the infectious and haemagglutination titres were similar to those obtained in the MDCK reference cell culture system.
Discussion
The results show that the new cell line of swine kidney origin was free of contaminants, was devoid of tumorigenic property, had the biological features typical of the swine species and was characterized by a high replication ability. It was capable of supporting the growth of several viruses causing trouble in pigs as well as of almost all the selected influenza virus types which had been isolated from the most common susceptible species.
References
This research was financially supported by the Italian Ministry of Health.
Antigenic and genetic characterisation of equine influenza AH3N8 viruses recently isolated in Europe.
A.J. Hay, A.R. Douglas, K.R. Cameron, M. S. Bennett, V. Gregory, I. Chizhmakov, G. Barigazzi,* M. Weiss,+ N. Nowotny.
National Institute for Medical Research, The Ridgeway, Mill Hill, London, NW7 1AA.
*
Instituto Zooprofilattico, Sperimentale della Lombardia e dell'Emilia, Via de Mercati 13/A, 43100 Parma, Italy.+
Institute of Veterinary Virology, University of Berne, Laenggass-Strasse 122, CH-3012 Berne, Switzerland. Institute fur Virologie, Veterinarmedizinische Universitat Wien, Veterinarplatz, A-1210, Wien, Austria.
Introduction
Of the two subtypes of influenza A viruses, H7N7 (equine-1) and H3N8 (equine -2), which are known to have caused significant disease in horses, only viruses of the latter H3N8 subtype have been isolated since about 1980. Since the initial isolation in 1963 of eq/Miami/1/63 (H3N8) an antigenically distinguishable variant appeared in 1967 (eq/France/67; eq/Fontainbleau/1/79-like) and subseqently replaced the eq/Miami/1/63-like viruses. These viruses have continued to evolve and in recent years two antigenically (and genetically) distinguishable variants have been responsible for disease among horses in Europe.
Results
Viruses isolated in Austria, Italy and Switzerland between 1995 and 1998 were compared in haemaglutination-inhibition (HI) tests using post-infection ferret sera and a panel of monclonal antibodies. Two principal antigenic variants were distinguished, one represented by eq/Suffolk/89 or eq/Newmarket/2/93, the other by eq/Newmarket/1/93 or eq/Kentucky/1/94. Viruses similar to the latter, which are representative of viruses prevalent in the Americas, were isolated from horses in Switzerland during 1995. The majority of recent European isolates were antigenically closely related to eq/Suffolk/89. The evolution of the viruses has been monitored by sequence analyses of the genes encoding their haemagglutinins and neuraminidases, and has identified amino acid differences characteristic of particular variants.
The M genes were also compared since a characteristic feature of eq/Fontainebleau/1/79-like viruses and subsequent variants, which distinguishes them from the earlier eq/Miami/1/63-like viruses and other influenza A viruses isolated from different species, is the presence of phenylalanine in place of cysteine 50 in the M2 proton channel. Phenylalanine at position 50, which precludes palmitoylation of M2, has been maintained in all recent equine virus isolates examined. Studies of the ion channel activities of the M2 proteins of selected equine viruses and M2 proteins specifically mutated at position 50 did not identify any changes in ion conductance properties resulting from substitution of cysteine 50 by phenylalanine. The possible significance of this unusual feature is as yet unknown.
Conclusion
Studies of recent equine H3N8 viruses indicated that they continue to evolve but did not reveal the emergence of an antigenically distinct variant among viruses recently isolated in Europe.
Studies of the circulation of individual lineages of H3N8 equine influenza virus in Sweden
L. Oxburgh1, Å. Karlsson2 & B. Klingeborn2
1Department of Veterinary Microbiology/Virology, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden
2
Department of Virology, National Veterinary Institute, Uppsala, SwedenIntroduction
Phylogenies of H3N8 equine influenza virus strains isolated from outbreaks in Europe have shown that two distinct evolutionary lineages of this virus exist; European and American. Serological studies have verified that lineage-specific antigenic differences can be found, raising the question of whether vaccination with virus belonging to one type affords sufficient protection against infection by virus belonging to the other type. Vaccines currently used in this country contain representatives of the European lineage only. Field reports support the idea that cross-protection is not sufficient, and that vaccine breakthroughs have become more common with the introduction of American-type strains into Sweden.
A major impediment to the surveillance of circulating H3N8 strains during recent years has been the difficulty to isolate virus. The cause of this apparent change in viral growth properties in embryonated hen´s eggs remains unclear. Since the updating of vaccine strains for use in the equine industry still relies on isolation of field strains, development of alternatives to virus isolation is a priority.
The aims of this study have been to;
i) Develop a nucleic acid based method for characterisation of circulating strains of H3N8.
ii) Define whether American-type virus strains are a common cause of equine influenza virus outbreaks in Sweden.
iii) Study whether adaptation of field strains of virus takes place upon isolation in embryonated hen´s eggs.
Materials and methods
Development of a diagnostic PCR method
Nested RT/PCR assays detecting the nucleoprotein (NP) and haemagglutinin (HA) genes of influenza virus were developed for use with nasal swab samples. When tested with a number of influenza viruses of diverse subtypes (H3N8, H7N7, H1N1, H3N2, H10N4 and H5N4), the NP assay was found to detect all of these, but the HA assay was specific for equine H3N8 virus. Both assays were found to amplify as little as 1-10 egg infectious units. The NP assay can thus be used to verify the presence of influenza virus in a clinical sample, and the HA assay can be used to specifically characterise virus strains through sequencing of the PCR product. Sequencing yields information both on epitopes and the receptor binding site of the protein.
Amplification of the entire HA gene from swab samples
In order to gain further sequence information from selected samples, a protocol was developed to amplify the entire coding sequence of the HA gene from swab material. This assay has lower sensitivity than the diagnostic method described above, being more dependent on the integrity of viral RNA in the sample.
Results
Specific amplification of influenza gene sequences from clinical samples
Nasal swab samples collected from horses during the 1997 Swedish equine influenza outbreak were assayed by RT/PCR assays detecting NP and HA. It was found that both assays secifically detected nucleic acid in swabs from horses which had previously tested positive by immunofluorescence (IF). In addition, some IF-negative samples tested positive in both RT/PCR assays. A titre-increase against H3N8 influenza virus was however detected in paired serum samples from these horses indicating that infection had indeed taken place. Nasal swabs collected on Iceland where equine influenza viruses are known not to circulate tested negative. In conclusion, the assay displays specificity and sensitivity.
Nucleotide sequencing of PCR products
Alignment and phylogenetic comparison of deduced amino acid sequences of the haemagglutinin gene generated from 20 samples revealed that 19 of these strains belonged to the American lineage of H3N8. Only one sample belonged to the European lineage. Furthermore, all of the virus sequences obtained from clinical material showed an amino acid change at position 190 of HA when compared with laboratory adapted American strains. Amino acid 190 forms the membrane-distal limit of the receptor binding pocket of HA, and changes at this position have been shown to affect utilisation of cell-surface receptors by the H3 virus of humans.
In order to investigate whether position 190 could be of significance in determining growth properties of recent strains in embryonated hens eggs, RT/PCR followed by sequencing was performed on serial passages of virus from clinical sample to high-yield laboratory stock. The amino acid at position 190 was indeed seen to mutate from lysine to glutamine at between passages 3 and 4. This change was concomitant with an increase in virus yield, as detected both by RT/PCR and haemagglutination assay. It thus appears that field isolates of American-type H3N8 do not grow to high titre in embryonated hen´s eggs without adaptation. This finding is novel, as it has been demonstrated that adaptation of the HA does not take place for European-type strains .
Discussion
The development of a sensitive and reliable RT/PCR method for the amplification of viral sequences from clinical samples containing H3N8 equine influenza virus enables efficient surveillance of circulating strains without the need for virus isolation. In addition, the amplification of entire coding regions of viral genes opens the possibility of constructing recombinant vaccines directly from diagnostic samples. Naked DNA vaccination, using HA and NP cloned in plasmid vectors under the control of strong eucaryotic promotors can elicit strong immune responses, as can viral genes expressed in other vector systems. The possible coupling of surveillance and vaccine development through the use of RT/PCR would facilitate prompt responses to outbreaks caused by newly introduced or mutated virus variants against which existing vaccine immunity is not sufficient.
The finding that the majority of strains of H3N8 equine influenza virus circulating in this country are of the American type strongly suggests that the European-type is being superseded by a variant against which exisiting immunity in the population is insufficient. Vaccines for use in this country should therefore be updated to include representatives of the American lineage.
The sequence divergence observed between field and laboratory adapted strains of American-type virus at position 190 of the HA could potentially be of great importance in receptor binding of the virus. Hydrogen bonding of the amino acid at this position with the sialic acid receptor stabilises the interaction, and has been shown to be of importance both for the specificity and the affinity of receptor binding. Inefficient binding of the wild-type HA to receptors in the allantoic membranes of embryonated hen´s eggs could explain the difficulties that have been experienced in isolating equine influenza virus since the introduction of American-type viruses in this country. Restriction at the level of receptor binding is unlikely to be the sole factor responsible for the need for virus adaptation to the culture system, as other proteins such as NP and PB2 have been shown to be of importance in controlling host-range restriction.
Genetic analysis of two equine influenza H3 viruses isolated in France.
S. Zientara1, J.-C. Manuguerra2, C. Sailleau1, C. Rousseaux2, B. Gicquel1, I. Rijks2 & S. van der Werf2
1CNEVA-LCRV 22 rue Pierre Curie 94 703 Maisons Alfort, 2 Institut Pasteur, Unité de Génétique Moléculaire des Virus Respiratoires
Introduction.
This paper reports the genetic analysis of two equine influenza viruses isolated in France in 1993 and in 1998.
In May 1993 several horses of a training center in Boissy-St-Léger (Grosbois) near Paris showed mild respiratory distress and fever. After renewed swabbing of the sick horses and 2 neighbouring horses, the collected specimens showed a positive reaction in an antigen capture ELISA.
An identical outbreak occured in April 1998 in the same training centrer. Samples were collected.
Materials and Methods.
Nasopharyngeal swabs were inoculated to embryonated henseggs and MDCK cells. Allantoic fluids that exhibited haemag-glutination activity were tested by haemagglutination inhibition tests for virus identification.
Results.
During the second and third egg passages, two influenza viruses (named A/Equi/Grosbois/1/93 [Groisbois/93] & A/Equi/Grosbois/1/98 [GroisBois/98]) were isolated from nasopharyngeal swabs. Both isolates were identified as influenza A/H3 viruses .
The nucleotide sequences of the HA1 genes of Grosbois/93 and Grosbois/98 were determined and the amino acid sequences deduced. Phylogenetic analysis of the amino acid sequences was carried out using the PHYLIP software package, version 3.573c (Felsenstein, 1993). The deduced amino acid sequence matrices were produced with PROTDIST, version 3.5c and branch lengths of the amino acid tree were calculated with FITCH, version 3.5c. The topology of the tree rooted with A/Jilin/1/89(H3N8), taken as the outgroup, placed the viruses in the European group.
Discussion.
This paper presents the description of two strains isolated in France from vaccinated individuals. Few data concerning the genetic analysis of French strains are available.
The horses were infected subclinically but excreted virus from the nasopharynx. The genetic analysis of these two viruses indicate that they belong to the European lineage (1). More precisely, the GroisBois/93 is on a branch close to, but diverging from, the group containing the current vaccinal strain A/Equi/ Fontainebleau/79(H3N8). This data is consistent with the hypothesis of " frozen or slow evolution " described for some equine viruses. The deduced amino acid sequence of HA1 of Gros Bois/93 shows a mutation (V78A) within the antigenic site E.
However, the genetic analysis placed Grosbois/98 very close to A/Newmarket/2/93(H3N8). Indeed, the deduced amino acid sequence of HA1 of GrosBois/98 shows that this strain carries the amino acid substitutions caracteristic of the "new" European ligneage, namely: V78D (site E), T163I (site B), N189K (site B), K207E (site D) and I213V (site D). This data confirms the necessity of including a strain representative of recent European variants in updated equine vaccines (2).
References
Alternative influenza vaccines: experiences with DNA vaccination
C. W. Olsen
Department of Pathobiological Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA
Introduction
In the United States, the influenza virus vaccines that are commercially-available for humans, horses and pigs are inactivated, whole virus or subunit vaccines. While these vaccines may decrease morbidity and disease severity, they do not consistently provide complete protection from infection. In contrast, recovery from experimental infection with influenza viruses in animals provides solid immunity to re-challenge. We seek to understand the immunological basis for this protection and to develop novel vaccines that will provide this same level of protection.
DNA vaccination involves administering plasmid DNA that encodes an immunogen of interest, in our case the hemagglutinin (HA) of influenza viruses, rather than administering that immunogen in protein form. The DNA can be administered by a variety of routes, including parenteral injection, mucosal application and gene gun transfection into the epidermis. One of its greatest advantages is the fact that antigens are synthesized de novo within transfected cells, and can thus be presented by both MHC I and II molecules to stimulate cellular as well as humoral immune responses. Beyond providing an exciting new approach to immunization, DNA vaccines also offer a powerful tool for modulating and understanding fundamental immune responses. We have investigated DNA vaccination against both equine and swine influenza viruses, beginning with studies in mice and then moving to horses and pigs. In several experiments, we have co-administered HA DNA and a second plasmid encoding interleukin-6 (IL-6) as a cytokine adjuvant.
Materials and Methods
Our studies have employed 2 well-characterized influenza viruses, A/Swine/Indiana/1726/88 (Sw/IN), an H1N1 swine influenza virus, and A/Equine Kentucky/1/81 (Eq/KY), an H3N2 equine influenza virus. The HA genes from these viruses were cloned by RT-PCR and ligated into eukaryotic expression vectors (PowderJect Vaccines, Inc., Madison, WI) that contain the immediate early promoter and intron A of human CMV and either the ampicillin or kanamycin resistance genes. For all of our studies, DNA vaccination was accomplished using the PowderJect-XR." gene gun (PowderJect Vaccines, Inc.), by which Qiagen-prepared plasmid DNA is precipitated onto 1-3m gold beads at a rate of 2.5m g DNA/mg gold and expelled from the gun using helium gas at 400-500psi. Mice received 2.5m g of HA DNA per vaccination, pigs received 7.5m g of HA DNA/dose and horses received 37.5-47.5m g of HA DNA/dose. In some experiments, animals received an equal amount of DNA encoding IL-6. In mice, a plasmid encoding human IL-6 was used. Human IL-6 is fully cross-functional in mice. For vaccination for pigs, the porcine IL-6 gene was cloned from porcine PBMC DNA following stimulation with LPS and conA (Dr. M. Murtaugh, University of Minnesota), and for our horse studies, equine IL-6 cDNA (provided by Dr. D. Horohov, Louisiana State U.) was similarly cloned into our expression plasmids. Gene gun-expressed IL-6 of each species was shown to be bioactive using the B9 cell assay (Dr. C. Czuprynski, U. of Wisconsin) and a Mab (Dr. D. Horohov) against the gp130 component of the IL-6 receptor. Mice were vaccinated twice at a 3-week interval and challenge infected 2 weeks after the second vaccination. Pigs were vaccinated twice at a 4-week interval and challenged 3 weeks after the second vaccination and horses were vaccinated 3 times at 65 day-intervals and challenged 4 weeks after the last vaccination. In all cases, challenge infection was accomplished by intranasal instillation of homologous virus. Protection was assessed in mice by measurement of virus titers in lungs, whereas protection in pigs and horses was assessed by quantification of virus shedding in nasal secretions. Serologic assays included isotype-specific ELISAs and hemagglutination-inhibition (HI) or virus neutralizing antibody assays on serum and nasal washes.
Results and Discussion
Our initial experiments in mice showed that the equine HA DNA vaccine could provide partial protection from challenge, but not the complete protection that we sought. The vaccines effectiveness was significantly enhanced (90% of vaccinated mice were completely protected) by delaying the time to administration of the booster dose of vaccine from 3 to 9 weeks. This is consistent with other DNA vaccine studies showing enhanced protection with a prolonged time to boosting.
Co-administration of huIL-6 DNA + the equine HA plasmid provided complete protection from challenge infection in mice, such that none of the HA + IL-6 DNA vaccinated mice had any detectable virus in their lungs after challenge. The addition of IL-6 DNA did not substantially enhance virus-specific serum antibodies or mucosal virus-specific IgA responses. Surprisingly, however, it did enhance virus-specific IgG levels in nasal secretions. A potential role for mucosal IgG in protection was also found in our studies of DNA vaccination in horses. In a study comparing DNA vaccination of horses in skin versus skin + mucosal sites (tongue and conjunctiva), as in the mice, protection against virus shedding was associated with the presence of virus-specific IgG (IgGb) in nasal secretions, and occurred in the absence of detectable IgA. In preliminary studies of HA + eqIL-6 DNA vaccination of horses, animals were again protected in the presence of virus-specific IgGb in serum and nasal secretions, but in the absence of IgA at the time of challenge. Yet we know from past studies that recovery from experimental influenza virus infection in horses induces strong nasal IgA responses. Thus, it is important to consider the possibility that DNA vaccines may induce protection via unique mechanisms, rather than by simply mimicking the responses to virus infection.
In pigs, our initial studies employed a low-dose approach to DNA vaccination. As in horses, administration of DNA to mucosal surfaces was superior to vaccination in the skin, but the animals did not seroconvert prior to challenge and were not protected virologically. Interestingly, however, the pigs were primed by DNA vaccination to develop very strong HI antibody responses after challenge, which is consistent with other studies demonstrating strong immune system priming by DNA vaccines. Thus, one approach that we are currently pursuing is to prime pigs by administration of the DNA vaccine and then boost them with a conventional protein vaccine. In addition, studies are underway to examine the response to a higher dose of DNA vaccine and to examine alternative sites of DNA vaccination.
This research was conducted by Drs. C. Olsen, D. Larsen, D.P. Lunn, G. Soboll and associates of the University of Wisconsin, and was supported by grants from the University of Wisconsin, the Grayson Jockey Club and the U.S. Department of Agriculture. We also thank Dr. W. Swain and colleagues at PowderJect Vaccines, Inc. for providing the gene gun technology for our use.
References
Protection of Chickens by Inactivated Avian Influenza Virus and Recombinant Fowl pox Vaccines From H5 Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza in the Face of Genetic Changes in Field Viruses Over Multiple Years
D.E. Swayne, M.L. Perdue, J.R. Beck and D.L. Suarez
Southeast Poultry Research Laboratory, USDA-ARS, Athens, Georgia, USA
Introduction
Traditionally, control of highly pathogenic (HP) avian influenza (AI) has been by stamping-out policies. Vaccine use has been limited to control programs against mildly pathogenic (MP) AI in turkeys in the Midwestern USA, and recently against HPAI in Pakistan and Mexico. In the USA, the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service has adopted a strategy for future control of HPAI that could potentially include vaccine use in a multifaceted emergency eradication program.
In humans, trivalent inactivated vaccines are central for the control and prevention of types A and B influenza, but because of antigenic changes, the vaccines have a finite life span and the composition is decided on an annual basis.
The following studies were conducted to determine if AI virus (AIV) vaccines against H5 HP AIV would need to be changed frequently to provide adequate protection.
Materials and methods
Experiment 1. Groups of 10 4-wk-old specific-pathogen-free (SPF) White Leghorn (WL) chickens were immunized subcutaneously with each of the 12 candidate inactivated AI vaccines prepared as described (1). Vaccines used included an uninoculated egg fluid, a H7 AIV and 10 H5 AIVs (Table 1). Challenge was at 3 wks post-vaccination (PV) by intranasal-(IN)-inoculation of 107.7 ELD50 of HP Chick/Que/14588/95 AIV. Oropharyngeal and cloacal swabs were taken at the peak of virus shedding, day 3 post-inoculation (PI), for virus isolation attempts in 10 day embryonating chicken eggs. The HA1 putative amino acid sequence similarity for vaccine and challenge viruses were determined.
Experiment 2. Ninety 1-day-old SPF WL chickens were immunized with a recombinant fowl pox vectored vaccine containing a hemagglutinin (HA) gene insert from Turkey/Ireland/83 (H5) (Vector-HA) (2). Ninety chickens were also immunized with the fowl pox vector (Vector-Control). At 3 weeks PV, 10 Vector-HA and 10 Vector-Control immunized chickens were IN challenged with 250 chicken lethal doses of one of nine different HP AIV (Table 2). Similar samples were taken as above.
Results
Experiment 1. The HA1 segment of the HA protein from the H5 vaccine viruses had 96.8-100% putative amino acid similarity to the HA1 of the HP H5 AIV. For the H5 vaccine groups, most immunized chickens lacked clinical signs and survived challenge by a HPAI H5 AIV (Table 1). The sham and H7 vaccine groups had 100% morbidity and 90% mortality rates after the same challenge. The challenge AIV was recovered frequently (83%) from the oropharyngeal cavity of chickens from all 12 groups on day 3 PI. The titres of AIV recovered were 101.3-3.5 ELD50/ml of media lower for H5 vaccinates as compared to the Sham or H7 groups. AIV was recovered less frequently from the cloaca of H5 immunized chickens (<20%) when compared to the Sham and H7 groups (60%). The virus titers were low for all cloacal samples.
Experiment 2. The HA1 and HA2 segments of the HA protein had 87.3-100% putative amino acid sequence similarity between the nine challenge AIV and the Vector-HA vaccine virus. The recombinant fowl pox-H5 vaccine provided complete protection from death following lethal challenge with the nine H5 HP AIV (Table 2). Vector-Control groups had challenge virus isolated from the oropharynx (90%) and cloaca (88%). Vector-HA groups had elimination or reduction to a minimum, challenge AIV detection from the cloaca in nine groups and from the oropharynx in all groups except Chicken/PA/1370/83 and Chicken/Queretaro/14588/95.
Table 1. Clinical signs and death patterns for chickens immunized with inactivated avian influenza vaccines and challenged with HP Chick/Que/14588-19/95 AIV strain.
|
Vaccine Group |
% HA Similarity |
Clinical Signs (%) |
Deaths (%) |
|||
|
Sham |
0 |
100 |
90 |
|||
|
Turkey/WI/68 (H5) |
96.8 |
10 |
10 |
|||
|
Turkey/OR/71 (H7) |
79.6 |
100 |
90 |
|||
|
Mallard/OH/556/87 (H5) |
97.7 |
0 |
0 |
|||
|
Chick/Mex/31381-7/94 (H5) |
98.9 |
0 |
0 |
|||
|
Chick/Mex/26654/94 (H5) |
98.2 |
10 |
10 |
|||
|
Turkey/MN/95 (H5) |
97.6 |
0 |
0 |
|||
|
Chick/Jal/14589-660/94 (H5) |
99.3 |
0 |
0 |
|||
|
Chick/Que/14588/95 (H5) |
100 |
0 |
0 |
|||
|
Chick/Ver/28159-398/95 (H5) |
99.3 |
10 |
10 |
|||
|
Chick/Pue/28159-488/95 (H5) |
97.7 |
10 |
10 |
|||
|
Chick/Chi/28159-488/95 (H5) |
96.9 |
0 |
0 |
|||
Table 2. Death rates for chickens immunized with Vector-Control (Control) and Vector-HA (HA) recombinant fowl pox vaccines and challenged with nine HP H5 AIV strains.
|
Challenge AIV |
% HA Similarity |
Death Rates (%) |
||||
|
Control |
HA |
|||||
|
Turkey/Ireland/83 |
100 |
100 |
0 |
|||
|
Turkey/England/91 |
94.2 |
100 |
0 |
|||
|
Tern/South Africa/61 |
93.1 |
100 |
0 |
|||
|
Chicken/Scotland/59 |
92.0 |
90 |
0 |
|||
|
Human/Hong Kong/156/97 |
90.2 |
80 |
0 |
|||
|
Chicken/Que/14588/95 |
89.3 |
10 |
0 |
|||
|
Turkey/Ontario/66 |
89.1 |
90 |
0 |
|||
|
Emu/TX/399924/93 |
88.8 |
70 |
0 |
|||
|
Chicken/PA/1370/83 |
87.3 |
100 |
0 |
|||
Discussion
The data demonstrates that frequent changing of H5 AI vaccines may not be necessary to provide effective protection from clinical signs and death caused by field viruses. Immunization with these vaccines should decrease AIV shedding from the oropharynx and cloaca of AIV exposed chickens. However, viruses with <90% homology at the HA between vaccine and challenge virus may not result in consistent reductions in AIV shedding from the oropharynx.
A comparative study of the antigenicity of two equine influenza vaccines in young thoroughbred horses
A.A. Cullinane, M. Osborne, T. Jackson, C. Brennan and M. Nelly.
The Virology Unit, Irish Equine Centre, Johnstown, Naas, Co. Kildare, Ireland.
Introduction
Research into methods for improving the protection provided by inactivated virus vaccines for equine influenza has concentrated on the development of adjuvants and the selection of antigens. Vaccines with adjuvants such as Carbomer or delivery systems such as immunostimulating complexes (ISCOMS) have been shown to be more immunogenic than vaccines containing virus in an aqueous suspension or combined with adjuvants such as aluminium hydroxide.
Equine influenza vaccines traditionally contain representatives of two equine virus subtypes A/Equine 1 (H7N7) and A/Equine 2 (H3N8). Most vaccines contain two H3N8 virus strains. Some contain the original prototype A/Miami/63 and a variant represented by the prototype A/Fontainbleau/79. However it is now widely accepted that Miami/63 is not antigenically representative of current strains. Since 1987 equine H3N8 viruses have diverged into two distinct lineages, one "European" and the other "American". WHO/0IE recommend that a Suffolk/89 and a Kentucky/94 like virus should be included in vaccines as representatives of both groups.
This study describes the serological response of young thoroughbred horses to vaccination with two vaccines containing different viruses and different adjuvants. Their antibody titres against the H7N7 prototype virus Prague/56 and three different H3N8 viruses were measured by the single radial haemolysis test. The H3N8 viruses were Brentwood/79 a Fontainbleau like virus, Kildare/89 a representative from the recent European lineage and Kildare/92 a representative from the recent American lineage (1).
Material & methods
Vaccines & Vaccination:
The vaccines used in this study were Vaccine D a carbomer adjuvanted vaccine containing inactivated Prague/56 (H7N7), Miami/63 (H3N8) and Suffolk/89 (H3N8) and Vaccine E an aqueous ISCOM vaccine containing inactivated Newmarket/77 (H7N7), Brentwood/79 (H3N8) and Borlange/91 (H3N8).
64 seronegative thoroughbred yearlings were divided into two groups of 32 on the same premises. Group A received vaccine D and Group B received vaccine E. They received their two primary doses of vaccine four weeks apart and a booster six months later.
Serology:
Clotted blood samples were collected at two weeks after the first vaccination (T1), four weeks after the first vaccination (T2), two weeks after the second vaccination (T3), three months after the second vaccination (T4), six months after the second vaccination (T5), two weeks after the third vaccination (T6) and six weeks after the third vaccination (T7). Sera were assayed for antibodies to representative antigens Prague/56 (H7N7), Brentwood/79 (H3N8), Kildare/89 (H3N8) and Kildare/92 (H3N8) by single radial haemolysis (2).
Statistical Analysis:
The Mann Whitney test was used to determine the statistical significance of differences between the results for the two groups.
Results & discussion
The carbomer vaccine elicited a greater SRH antibody response to the prototype H7N7 virus Prague/56 throughout the trial. However type 1 influenza has not been conclusively identified as a cause of respiratory disease in horses for more than a decade. Thus it is H3N8 influenza viruses that are of major economic concern to the horse industry at present. The carbomer vaccine elicited a significantly greater antibody response to all three H3N8 antigens two and four weeks after the first vaccination than did the ISCOM vaccine. This vaccine also elicited a greater response to Kildare/89 throughout the trial. The results for the other H3N8 viruses Brentwood/79 and Kildare/92 were more equivocal. After the second vaccination there was no significant difference in the SRH titres of Groups A and B at the majority of time points. At the final time point six weeks after the third dose of vaccine, the mean titre for Group A against Brentwood/79 was 158 mm2, Kildare/89 146 mm2 and Kildare/92 125 mm2. The mean titres for Group B at this time point were 166 mm2 for Brentwood/79, 123 mm2 for Kentucky/89 and 142 mm2 for Kentucky/92.
A direct relationship between antibody to haemagglutinin as measured by single radial haemolysis and protection against infection with H3N8 equine influenza viruses has been established (2). In one experimental study horses with antibody levels greater than 120 mm2 were protected against infection and those with antibody levels of 92 mm2 were protected against disease (2). Thus both groups of horses had protective antibody levels against H3N8 equine influenza viruses at the end of the study when they were due to enter the training yards. The antibody titres in Group A and B did not differ significantly at this time for Brentwood/79. Group A had significantly higher titres than Group B against Kildare/89 and the reverse was true for Kildare/92. Thus at this time point it would seem that there was little to choose between the two vaccines. However, the results of the study suggests that the carbomer vaccine offered greater protection after the first dose of vaccine and that it would be the vaccine of choice if the H7N7 viruses were to re-emerge as a problem.
References
Protection of mice with zanamivir and rimantadine after infection infected with A/HongKong/156/97 (H5N1)with zanamivir and rimantadine
Larisa V. Gubareva1, Jonathan A. McCullers2, Richard C. Bethell3, and Robert G. Webster2.
1
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Virginia, USA;2
Department of Virology/Molecular Biology, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, USA; 3Department of Enzyme Pharmacology, Glaxo Wellcome, UK.Introduction
Influenza A/Hong Kong/156/97 (H5N1) (abbreviated hereafter as HK/97), aA highly virulent virus of avian origin, caused an outbreak of influenza in Hong Kong in 1997 (1,2). Concern that the appearance of such a virus in the human population may be a sentinel event preceding warning of a new pandemic has brought increased attention to the measures to for the control of influenza. A/Hong Kong/156/97 (H5N1), the first of H5N1 subtype isolated from a human host (1,2). Because the introduction of such a virus into the human population represents a shift in the surface antigens HA and NA, the vaccines in use at the time of introduction would not be protective. Amantadine and rimantadine, are effective in against influenza A virus infection; however, the utilization of these antivirals is limited by rapid emergence of drug-resistant mutants and by side effects of the drugs themselves. A novel anti-influenza drug, zanamivir, has demonstrated efficacy against influenza A and B infection in mice, and ferrets, and in humans and is well-tolerated and is well-tolerated (3). However, despite the high potency of zanamivir against the NA of highly virulent avian influenza viruses in vitro, the drug has failed to protect chickens against several fowl plague strains. It iswas therefore important to investigate whether zanamivir has efficacy against this particular virus strain in a mammalian system.
Materials and mmethods
H/K97 HK/97 was cultured from a patient who died of influenza infection in May of 1997. Virus was passaged in MDCK cells then passaged twice in mouse lungs and propagated in embryonated chicken eggs.
Plaque reduction and neuraminidase inhibition (NI) assays were performed as described (4).
As am animal model of infection HK/97, 8-12-weeks-old BALB/c mice were anesthetized by inhalation of metofane and inoculated intranasally with 100 µl of a virus suspension. The virus challenge dose contained 3 MLD50 of HK/97. Zanamivir administration was performed was administered by intranasal inoculation (IN) in anesthetized mice to deliver the drug topically to the lungs. Rimantadine was given orally without anesthesia. Mice were prophylaxed and treated 24h and 4h before infection, then 4h after infection and twice daily for 5 days. A mean survival day (MSD) was calculated using the following formula: MSD =[f(d-1)] / N where f is the number of mice recorded dead on day d (survivors on day 18 were included in f for that day), and N is the number of mice in a group.
Results
Experiment 1: Inhibition of HK/97 by antivirals in vitro:
In NI assays, the NA of this strain was highly sensitive to zanamivir, with an IC50 value of 0.3 ng/ml. We then assessed the effect of zanamivir on virus spread during replication by a plaque reduction assay on MDCK cells. The IC50 value for plaque size was 0.3 ng/ml, and the IC90 value for plaque number wasof 30 ng/ml. Virus was also sensitive to rimantadine with an IC50 value equal to 10 ng/ml for plaque size and an IC90 value of 100 ng/ml for plaque number.
Experiment 2: HK/97 pathogenicity in mice
To determine pathogenicity of the virus in a mouse model, groups of 9 animals were infected with 10-fold dilutions of the virus. To estimate the dose infectious to 50% of the mice (MID50), 5 mice from each group were sacrificed on day 3 p.i., and their lung homogenates were used to titer the virus. The virus grew readily and to high titers in mouse lungs. The MID50 for HK/97 was ~ 1.5 PFU. A lethal dose for 50% of the inoculated mice (MLD50) was estimated at ~3 PFU. Therefore, we have establishedThis establishes that HK/97 is highly virulent in this animal model.
Experiment 3: Reduction of virus titers
We examined the effect of zanamivir on infection with HK/97 by determining virus titer in the lungs. Mice infected with ~3 MLD50 were prophylaxed and treated with 25 mg/kg/day of the drug or with water instilled intranasally. Zanamivir reduced the virus titers by ~2 logs compared to controls. All mice in the control group had died by day 6 p.i.
Table 1. Virus titers in lungs of mice prophylaxed and treated with zanamivir.
|
Group |
log10 of TCID50/ml on day p.i. |
||||
|
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
|
|
Zanamivir |
4.5 |
5.5 |
5.5 |
5.7 |
5.5 |
|
Control |
6.2 |
7.8 |
8.2 |
7.2 |
N/A |
Experiment 4: prophylaxis and treatment
Groups of mice were prophylaxed and treated with either zanamivir (2.5 orand 25 mg/kg/d) or with rimantadine (10 orand 100 mg/kg/d). Mice in the zanamivir-group had a longer MSD and more survivors than in rimantadine- and in control groups.
Table 2. Reduction in mortality of mice prophylaxed and treated with zanamivir and rimantadine for HK/97 infection
|
Treatment, mg/kg/day |
MSD |
Survivors/Total |
|
Zanamivir, 2.5 |
14.1 |
6/10 |
|
Zanamivir, 25 |
16.1 |
9/10 |
|
Control, H2O I/N |
8.7 |
1/10 |
|
Rimantadine, 10 |
11.9 |
4/10 |
|
Rimantadine, 100 |
15.3 |
8/10 |
|
Control, H2O PO |
9.6 |
1/10 |
Discussion
In the present study, we establish the virulence of influenza HK/97 (H5N1) in a mammalian model and demonstrate that intranassally administered zZanamivir and orally given rimantadine provided protection from lethal challenge compared to controls as measured by three indices: decrease in viral lung titers, decrease in morbidity as assessed by weight loss (not shown), and decrease in mortality both absolutely by numbers surviving and by time between infection and death as the MSD or mean survival day. These data provide a rationale for further study of zanamivir and related drugs in the treatment of avian influenza viruses with the potential to cross the species barrier and infect humans.However, it is important to point out that the data reported here is for prophylaxis and treatment of disease and may not reflect the outcome in the situation of delayed treatment.
References
This work was supported by Public Health research grants AI-08831 from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, (CORE) grant CA-21765, and ALSAC.
Immunogenicity of influenza glycoproteins with different forms of supramolecular organization
A.P. Bogoyavlenskiy, V.E. Berezin, A.V. Ogneva, V.P. Tolmacheva, I.E. Digel
Laboratory of Antivirus Protection, Institute of Microbiology & Virology, Almaty, Kazakhstan
Introduction
The way the antigen is presented to the immune system is often critical to obtain a functional immune response. It has been shown that an antigen can be more immunogenic when it is presented in an aggregated, colloidal form, for instance as protein micelle (1,2). Solubilized enveloped glycoproteins of influenza virus are readily assembled into different molecular complexes such as micelles, liposomes and ISCOMs by means of hydrophobic interactions of hydrophobic transmembrane domens. Therefore alteration of the supramolecular form of isolated glycoproteins is one of the possible ways for increasing immunogenicity.
The aim of this study is to investigate of immunogenic activity of different antigen structures ( micelles, ISCOMs) prepared from purified glycoprotein antigens of influenza virus (strain A/FPV/Rostock/34).
Material and methods
For successful solubilisation and controlled organization of high immunogenic complexes of purified FPV glycoproteins we have used new non-ionic dialysable detergent MESK synthesized on the base of sugars and fatty acids in Kazakhstan (3).
Purified glycoproteins of FPV in the form of micelles and ISCOMs and whole purified virus were used for immunisation of hens. After twice subcutaneous immunisation blood samples were taken during 10-month period and sera were analysed in dot-EIA and hemagglutinin-inhibition tests. Yolk of immune hen eggs were analysed too.
Results
For investigation of the immunogenicity of different FPV glycoprotein antigen structures hens were immunized of equal doses of glycoprotein micelles, formalinized whole virus, complex of glycoproteins with glycoside Quil A, glycoproteins mixed with complete Freund's adjuvant. Presented results (table 1) have demonstrated that different
Table 1. Titer of antibodies in sera of hens immunized different forms of FPV glycoprotein antigens(dot-EIA)
|
Group |
Days after immunization |
||||
|
35 |
56 |
77 |
98 |
300 |
|
|
1a |
1600 |
400 |
400 |
200 |
100 |
|
2b |
3200 |
400 |
200 |
100 |
100 |
|
3c |
6400 |
6400 |
1600 |
800 |
400 |
|
4d |
6400 |
1600 |
1600 |
800 |
400 |
a
glycoprotein micelles, b formalinized whole virus, c complex of glycoproteins with glycoside Quil A, d glycoproteins mixed with complete Freund's adjuvantmolecular forms of isolated virus antigens possessed different immunogenic activity. Most immunogenicity possess complexes ISCOM. The immunogenicity of ISCOM was compared with the immunogenicity of glycoprotein micelles myxed with one of the most strong immunopotentiators complete Freunds adjuvant.
Serum collection in poultry required special handling that can cause a great deal of trauma and risks stressing flocks and exposing them to new pathogens. These factors and the costs they present limit the frequency of flock antibody monitoring that can be done by avian practitioners. The use of egg yolk as a source of antibody provides an alternative to serum. Although the technique for using yolk antibody has been available for some time, its field application for flock monitoring following vaccination has yet to be exploited.
In this report we were used yolk antibody for determination level of immune response to vaccination by glycoproteins of FPV ( Table 2). But serum collection leaded up to reducing egg generation, therefore we not may were used all variants of yolk egg samples.
Table 2. Comparison of antibody titers in sera of hens and yolk eggs after immunized of hens different forms of FPV glycoprotein antigens by hemagglutinin-inhibition test
|
Group |
hens |
yolk eggs |
|
1a |
40 |
20 |
|
2b |
40 |
20 |
|
3c |
80 |
40 |
|
4d |
80 |
40 |
a
glycoprotein micelles, b formalinized whole virus, c complex of glycoproteins with glycoside Quil A, d glycoproteins mixed with complete Freund's adjuvantDiscussion
The results obtained showed that different molecular forms of antigens stimulated different levels of humoral immunity. ISCOMs are the best immunostimulating form of purified FPV glycoproteins stimulating a higher level of humoral immunity than whole virus or glycoprotein micelles. ISCOMs stimulated a high level of antibodies in egg-yolk too. Egg-yolk antibody titers were correlated with the level of serum antibodies.
References
This research was financially supported by the Kazakhstanian Ministry of Science-Academy of Sciences.
Efficacy of remantadin against fowl influenza
I.K. Avdosjeva, I.L. Melnychuk, V.V. Regenchuk, O.B. Basarab
State scientific-research control institute of veterinary preparations and fodder additives, L`viv, Ukraine.
Introduction
Chicken influenza in the form of classical plague (FCP) is registrated quite seldom. However, in some countries of the world this infection becomes apparent by epizootic out-breaks, caused by influenza virus strains of other subtypes, that are characterized by low pathogenicity in comparison with virus of FCP. At the same time respiratory diseases, particularly epizootics of influenza among chickens, often coincide in time with epidemics of this disease among people or appear a little bit later. Repeatedly these varieties of influenza virus were isolated from infected chickens and synanthropic birds that caused diseases in them and often had similar antigens to viruses actual for a man.
Great attention is given to a search of effective chemical preparations and to development of methods of their application during influenza infection in chickens.
Material and methods
Under productive conditions we studied the efficacy of such preparation as remantadin (a derivative of amantadin) during outbreak of influenza that appeared among 120 days old chickens. The infected birds had blue colored combs, nasal excretions, breath difficulties, refusals of feed, paresis. The death rate of the birds was 10-15%/ The influenza etiology of this outbreak was stated on the basis of results of blood serological researches with the help of the agglutination inhibition test (AIT) with 10 antigens: A/PR-8-34-GONI, A/FM/1/47, SRSR/77-GINI, A/Singapore/57-2, A/Hong-Kong/1/68, England/72, A/Port Chalmers/173-G3n2, A/pig/Iowa/15/30-G, sv/N/, B/Japan/73. A high level of antibodies of 4 2 log to antigen of influenza virus of type A/GINI in 72% of tested blood serum of chickens was stated.
The therapeutic action of remantadin was studied during influenza outbreak among 120 days old chickens with population of 22300 birds. In the control group infected birds were given erythromycin together with feed in a dose of 35 mg/kg b.w. during 5 days.
Remantadin was used in the form of spray with the help of an apparatus SAG at 200 mg/m3 and with exposure time of 20 minutes for 3 days. There was carried out a daily clinical examination of the birds and the account was kept for the dead poultry. In 21 day the level of specific antibodies in both groups in reaction of hemagglutination delay was defined.
Results
After application of remantadin in 5-7 days of treatment clinical signs of influenza disappeared, death rate and discarding of birds reduced for 3,8%. Titers of specific antibodies were found in 5,2% of tested sera, while in the group of chickens treated with erythromycin it was 21%. The therapeutic effect of remantadin against fowl influenza made up 85,7%.
Discussion
The present (given) result confirm high therapeutic efficacy of remantadin during treatment of influenza in fowl in comparison with erythromycin. Such reliable method as spray application of remantadin allows to decrease its quantity and to cut down expenses for its purchase, as well as raises the drug efficacy.
| Click button to go |
![]() |
back to our home page |